Roper Mens Trot Shoe, Tan, 11.5 Review
The Roper Mens Trot Shoe in Tan is a prime example of where style meets functionality. Constructed from full grain crazy horse leather, these mules are designed to provide not only a fashionable look but also exceptional performance. The forged steel shank embedded within offers enhanced support and stability, making them an excellent choice for everyday wear or specialized activities.
One of the standout features of these shoes is the soft support inner sole, which molds to your foot for added comfort. The double stitch seams ensure durability, allowing you to enjoy these shoes for years to come. Furthermore, the stirrup-friendly non-marking outsole means that whether you’re riding or walking, you won’t leave a trace behind.
Features
- Material: 100% Leather
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Flexible and non-marking outsole
- Mule design for easy slip on/off
- Steel shank for enhanced stability
Pros
- Stylish tan color suitable for various occasions
- Comfortable inner sole for long-lasting wear
- Durable construction with double stitch seams
- Stirrup-friendly design for equestrian activities
- Lightweight and flexible for ease of movement
Cons
- Limited color options
- May require breaking in for optimal comfort
- Not waterproof; care needed in wet conditions
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Shank Support | Outsole Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roper Mens Trot Shoe | Full Grain Leather | Forged Steel | Non-marking Rubber |
| Ariat Men’s Rambler Western Boot | Premium Full Grain Leather | Composite | Durable Outsole |
| Justin Boots Men’s Gypsy Collection | Leather | Steel | Slip-Resistant Outsole |
Detailed Review
The Roper Mens Trot Shoe stands out in terms of comfort, thanks to the soft support inner sole that conforms to your foot, providing excellent cushioning throughout the day. Whether you're spending hours on your feet or just running errands, you will appreciate the level of comfort these shoes deliver.
In addition to comfort, the shoe's construction deserves attention. The use of full grain crazy horse leather not only gives it a rugged yet stylish appearance but also enhances its durability. You can trust that these mules will withstand daily wear and tear without compromising on quality.
When it comes to performance, the forged steel shank offers substantial support and stability, ensuring that your feet remain protected during various activities, be it riding or simply walking. The flexible sole allows for natural foot movement, further contributing to the overall pleasant wearing experience.
However, it is important to note that while the Roper Mens Trot Shoe excels in many areas, potential buyers should consider the limited color options available, as well as the need for a breaking-in period. Additionally, if you frequently encounter wet conditions, you might want to avoid these shoes as they are not waterproof.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 4.5/5 | Exceptional cushioning and support for extended wear |
| Durability | 4.7/5 | High-quality materials ensure lasting performance |
| Style | 4.3/5 | Classic and versatile tan design suitable for various settings |
| Performance | 4.6/5 | Excellent stability and flexibility, ideal for active use |
User Reviews
First off, I usually wear a 10 medium, I ordered an 11 based on previous reviews of it running small. The instep where you slide your foot into IS kinda tight, but I assumed that there would be some stretch, and there was. It is a mostly flat insole, not much of an arch support. So if you have a high arch it might not work for you. I broke these shoes in by starting out in bare feat in the shoe. After walking around the in the house for about a week off and on I can feel it had stretched a bit. I then went to thin socks. As the shoe stretches it also formed to my foot well. This is a slide in, slide off shoe that I usually wear around the house. They work for me.
I really would like to wear these shoes more often. I need a shoe horn to get them on my feet. I am keeping them, but probably I should have a half size larger. It is one challenge of ordering shoes on the internet...
Had an old pair of slides, that I wore until they just about literally fell off my feet. Finally, bit the bullet, and bought something (slightly) different, since I could no longer find those. I love these shoes! They're comfortable, right out of the box, the color is great, they darkened with just a little bit of oil...and they're EASY to kick on and off at the front door!
Read some reviews that said these run small, so I ordered a half size larger. The problem is not really the overall size, it's that the part of the shoe running across the top of your foot is low and has no give. If you have medium to high arches, you won't be able to get your foot all the way into the shoe. (I even tried shoe stretcher spray that I bought on Amazon. No dice.) Since I get get my foot all the way in, my heel pushes out the back, sitting over or too tightly against the back lip, and it wore that part of the shoe out quickly. Already worn through in a couple of months. It's a shame because it's otherwise a well constructed, nice looking shoe. If you have flat feet, it's probably a good shoe.
I normally take a size 11.5 to 12 shoe. I saw that many people had mentioned in their reviews that these ran small, so I made sure to use the fitting guide provided to select the right size for me to order. It said that size 12 should be right for me so that's what I ordered. The shoes came early on the second day after I had ordered them and I put on some thin dress socks and tried them on. Or, more accurately, I attempted to try them on. I couldn't get more then half my foot into the shoe. Maybe I just have fat feet. Maybe it's because I have a high instep. Maybe it's because these shoes don't have any elastic on either side of where the tongue would be if they had laces like many other slip-on shoes have.Whatever the reason, they're going back. If you're a thin person with a low instep these might work for you, but they don't for me.
Despite all reviews saying they run small, i still bought regular size. They were hard to get my foot all the way in. Then liberally rubbed down with rubbing alcohol and directly after alcohol use petroleum jelly. Then went around each stretching it and wore rest of day. Next morning they were perfect fit.
The shoes are well made and once you figure out the size you need, they are quite comfortable. They were for my son, who normally wears a 10. I first ordered a 10 1/2 and they were too small. He asked for an 11 1/2 and they fit great!
They look great fit very well thanks to the other reviewers that recommend to go up a size I wear 11 wide so I ordered size 12 wide very glad I did I am sure 11 would of been too small