Fireside by Dearfoams Women's Rosebery Genuine Shearling Water Resistant Boot Review

I really love these boots. Good quality. Reviews said to size up. I can usually wear 6.5 or 7. I ordered these in 7.5 and they fit perfectly… maybe the tiiiiiiniest snug but a good snug.

Wow!!!! Okay so first off, these are real suede leather and shearling! So these are 100% comparable to brand name boots that are double the price. Don’t get me wrong, I love Ugg boots, but these are amazing for the price. I think they take the cake over the name brand in terms of comfort and warmth, too. These are SO comfortable. Very soft and conform to the foot. They are light weight and nothing stiff anywhere, but the sole feels protective and they are waterproof. I love the pink color I got. They’ve been wet and stained and clean up beautifully! I’ve been living in them. They’ve been worn everyday for about 6 weeks now in nasty weather and as you see, they look brand new in my picture still (the toe is wet at the moment). Would make amazing slippers too! They fit perfectly true to size to me. Definitely not small. I even ordered a size down because I thought my true size felt a smidge large at first, but the size down felt like a size down, so I stuck with my true size and they’re perfect. I wear them without socks as they’re intended to be worn, but there is enough room for socks if I wanted. You won’t be disappointed in this purchase!

These are a great lower-cost alternative to Uggs. I’ve owned several pairs of Uggs and love them but money is tight for me and they are outside my budget now. These are a good option.Pros: first, cost is amazing compared to Uggs. Second, the shearling is high quality and the suede looks and feels good, not overly scraped or thin at all. Very high quality inside and out. Third, the grey color looks great, a nice even dark grey color. Last, the fit is great. Some Ugg alternatives are too low over the arch, which makes them too tight and hard to get on and off. These don’t have that problem at all. The fit it roomy and comfortable without slipping.Cons: first, you need to size up 1/2 to 1 size. I wear an 8 in Uggs. Amazon recommended an 8.5 based on my history and how these fit others. After reading the reviews I decided to get a 9 and I’m glad I did. Second, there’s no loop on the back seam where can slide in a finger to tug them on. The fit is good so it isn’t that difficult to pull them on, but that is the sort of detail Uggs offers that these don’t. Third, the shearling I solve isn’t removable so you can’t replace it, something else the higher priced Uggs offers. Last, the sole doesn’t seem to flex as much, and it’s more rigid. It doesn’t bend much at the ball of the foot when I push off.I think all the cons are manageable given the price difference. I just wish the color range was broader.

Okay y'all. I read through many of these reviews and decided to follow suit and order a whole size up. I'm rating 5 stars because these shoes are great even though so many of these reviews are trash.These are NOT boots. These are indoor/outdoor slippers. They do NOT run small (for my feet, I'll speak for myself) they just aren't meant to wear with thick winter socks, or likely any socks at all. I am about two weeks into my wear of these, and they are sloshing around on my feet, even with socks on. Once the fluffiness of the fur starts to pack down, the true size of the shoe takes shape. This was the case for me wearing them with and without socks. I'm stuck with these now, but they're so nice I might pass them to a friend and get another pair that fit me properly.Bottom line: It's misleading to keep telling Amazon that these run small, when in fact, they are the right size for feet that want to slip into shearling heaven and go. Complaining that they don't fit with your thick wool winter socks is silly. That's not on the manufacturer, that's on you! These are advertised as something you can "go to the mailbox" wearing. These aren't meant for solid winter boot activities, especially if you live in any city. So please stop saying they run small. Order up if you want to wear them with thick socks, order your size if you just want to "go to the mailbox", or in my case, walk the dog in them.

The dye on the shearling turns my feet black. Too bad because they are wildly comfortable.

Good quality shearling. Very comfortable.

Absolutely fantastic. I don't want to shell out the money to buy a brand name, and these were more affordable than Uggs and even the Bearpaw/Koolaburra equivalent. Before buying these, I bought some other versions from a no-name brand and they were fake shearling, super heavy, and not very comfortable. Returned them and got these. Can't recommend enough. We'll see how they hold up in wetter weather - I tend to avoid wearing them if it's really wet but so far they haven't stained or scuffed at all. The height is perfect - they show off my socks but are still warm and cozy.

Every shoe I have is a size 9.5, so that is what I ordered. Upon arrival, I put them on and my feet felt..... squished. I do understand that they will "stretch out" (I have had the similar, more expensive brand before); but, these simply felt tight all over - at the instep, at the toes, and at the length. I did notice that there is lots of the shearling on the inside, so, perhaps, that contributes to the feeling small.I returned that pair to order another in a size up. I am definitely hoping for a good fit from sizing up as these did seem to be well made and warm.