Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Snow Boot Review: Dove/Stratus, Size 7.5
The Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Snow Boot is designed to tackle winter’s harshest conditions while keeping you looking stylish. These boots combine functionality with a chic aesthetic, making them an ideal choice for women who want to stay fashionable without sacrificing warmth or performance.
Constructed from a mix of 100% leather and textile, these boots feature a waterproof upper that ensures your feet remain dry even in heavy snow. With a shaft height that reaches the ankle, they offer adequate support and protection against colder temperatures.
Related Products
Features
- Advanced Technology: Waterproof leather upper with seam-sealed membrane bootie construction and TECHLITE lightweight midsole for long-lasting comfort and cushioning.
- Style Meets Function: A quilted design provides ankle support while offering plenty of flex for ease of movement.
- All Weather Traction: Omni-GRIP non-marking rubber outsole grants versatility for both outdoor and indoor use.
- Cozy Warmth: Soft faux fur collar and excellent 200g insulation keep your feet warm during cold weather.
- Temperature Ratings: Rated for extreme conditions at -25F/-32C.
Pros
- Stylish design suitable for various occasions.
- Excellent insulation keeps feet warm.
- Waterproof construction protects against moisture.
- Lightweight build enhances comfort during wear.
- Durable traction for safe navigation on icy surfaces.
Cons
- May feel snug for those with wider feet.
- Limited color options available.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II | North Face Shellista IV | Sorel Joan of Arctic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waterproof | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Insulation | 200g | 200g | 196g |
| Traction Outsole | Omni-GRIP | Winter Grip | Rubber |
| Temperature Rating | -25F/-32C | -25F/-32C | -40F/-40C |
Detailed Review
The Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Snow Boot is a reliable choice for winter footwear, especially if you're seeking a blend of comfort, style, and practicality. Here’s a closer look at its performance across different categories:
Comfort: The TECHLITE midsole makes a significant difference in cushioning and energy return, allowing you to walk longer distances without discomfort. The faux fur collar adds extra coziness around the ankles, which is particularly appreciated during freezing temperatures.
Design: The boot's aesthetic is undeniably feminine, adorned with a quilted finish that elevates its visual appeal. It pairs well with both casual and more dressed-up winter outfits, ensuring that functionality doesn’t compromise style.
Performance: When it comes to battling the elements, the waterproof nature and outstanding insulation make these boots highly reliable. They can withstand heavy snowfall and are rated for extremely low temperatures, making them perfect for severe winter conditions.
Traction: The Omni-GRIP outsole provides excellent grip on slippery surfaces, essential for navigating snowy streets or hiking in icy conditions.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | The boots provide exceptional comfort, thanks to their cushioning and soft materials. |
| Style | 8/10 | A fashionable design that easily transitions between outdoor activities and casual outings. |
| Performance | 9/10 | Reliable insulation and waterproofing for harsh winter weather. |
| Traction | 8/10 | Good grip on various terrains, ensuring safety when walking on ice. |
| Value for Money | 8/10 | A solid investment for a stylish and functional winter boot. |
User Reviews
This boot is comfortable and cute. Keeps my feet warm and easy to put on. I'm a size 8.5Reading the reviews I bought an 8.5W. Which fits fine and allows me to wear a second pair of socks.
I have searched and tried on so many boots to find something that works and has a wide toe box. These boots meet those expectations! I am able to move my toes around without feeling squished, my feet are warm with a heavy sock but also too warm at times so lighter socks also work for me. They are waterproof so far in wet, snowy conditions, and are comfortable for walking distances. I've walked a couple of miles and worn them for several hours and don't have sore feet afterwards. The price was great at less than $70, partly because I chose the black versus more stylish colors. They seem like great boots and will hopefully last a few seasons of wear.
Typically I wear a size 10 women’s (medium width) or a size 8 men’s (medium width). I needed boots for an upcoming trip and initially purchased these in medium width. They look great and check all the boxes in color, comfort, and warmth. However, the medium width boots wouldn’t have left much room for thick wool socks, which I’ll need. So, I decided to purchase these in a 10.5 wide width and I am so thankful for all the reviews that recommended the wide width and sizing up. I only went up a half-size. Normally I couldn’t wear a wide width shoe/boot; however, these are wonderful. They are roomy, as seen in the photos. However, I had on thin socks and still no sloshing around in them. Also, I hiked in a nature preserve with muddy, rocky terrain with elevation variations, these boots handled every twist and turn with ease. My feet feel fantastic and interestingly, my legs didn’t feel as heavy or fatigued as they often are when I’m wearing my hiking shoes.I highly recommend these boots to anyone looking for comfort, cuteness, and a boot that can handle whatever path one takes!
I love these boots! I read that they can run small, so I bought a 9 Wide when I wear 9 in regular shoes. They fit perfectly. I am a dog walker, and while trudging through the snow in single digits, these boots kept my feet warm and dry the entire time. They have good support, but since I have plantar fascitis, I inserted additional orthotic insoles for optimal comfort. The boots have a rocking back and forth motion while walking, which I find comfortable. There is good support for the ankles as well. No snow gets in, and you can tighten the laces at the top to keep everything even drier. The only issue I have is that the traction isn't very good if you walk on ice or even sidewalks with a thin layer of snow. It is very slippery. Other than that, I love these boots and will order them again!
Super warm, I wear these everyday to walk my dog in the winter. Waterproof toe and heal is great for walking in the snow. The grip is great, I rarely even slip on ice in these. Slight large around the ankle but otherwise fits well.
These came up in a search for an expensive brand name and I thought I was ordering something else! I can’t believe what a steal these are. I have an old injury on my right foot that makes it hard to find shoes that don’t hurt in the toe - but I ordered a half size up wide and they’re great. Cute, warm, perfect for mammoth trips, and didn’t cost a fortune!
Excellent boot. I have wide feet and a previously broken one that gives me issues. I was iffy about these boots but DON’T BE. They’re so great that I’ve used them for jogging in this nasty winter weather we’ve been having. Not once have my feet been cold or wet. I wear thin socks and jog along merrily. I have the black and love the way they look with my leggings. The laces are good and strong too. Super comfy boot.
I'm really happy with these boots. They keep your feet toasty and they are stylish enough to wear daily. I typically wear an 8.5 but sized up to 9 and thought I would try the "wide" size. My foot is 4" at the widest part, there is plenty of room still. I thought I had wide feet but apparently not! I see why people size up for boots but I think the 8.5 would've worked just as well.