Stacy Adams Men's Tinsley-Wingtip Oxford, Tan/Brown, 12 M US Review
The Stacy Adams Men's Tinsley-Wingtip Oxford is a quintessential choice for those seeking a blend of classic style and contemporary comfort. The wing-tip design, adorned with brogue perforated trims, adds a touch of sophistication that makes these shoes suitable for both formal and casual occasions. With a color combination of tan and brown, they can seamlessly integrate into any wardrobe.
Features
- Classic Wing-tip lace-up design
- Brogue perforated trims enhance aesthetic appeal
- Blind-eyelet lacing for a polished look
- Fully cushioned memory foam insole for enhanced comfort
- Flexible sole with detailed stitching for traction
- Lightweight yet durable construction
- Breathable linings for all-day wear
Pros
- Stylish and versatile design
- Exceptional comfort due to memory foam insole
- Diverse applications, perfect for business or casual settings
- Quality build ensures longevity
- Good traction thanks to flexible sole
Cons
- Fit may run small, advisable to size up if in between
- Machine washing may affect the leather over time
- Limited color options available
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Style | Comfort | Durability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stacy Adams Men's Tinsley-Wingtip | Wingtip Oxford | Superior with Memory Foam | High |
| Clarks Men's Tilden Cap Oxford | Cap Toe Oxford | Moderate with Ortholite Footbed | Medium |
| Johnston & Murphy Men's Conard Oxford | Classic Oxford | Very Good with Cushioned Insole | High |
Detailed Review
When it comes to footwear, few brands can match the legacy of Stacy Adams, particularly with their Men's Tinsley-Wingtip Oxford. This shoe is more than just a pretty face; it embodies quality craftsmanship paired with modern comfort technology.
One of the most notable aspects of this shoe is its classic wing-tip design, which has been reimagined for today’s fashion-forward gentlemen. The intricate brogue detailing not only enhances visual interest but also signifies the timelessness of this form. You will find these shoes to be quite versatile, making them ideal for various occasions, from corporate environments to evening gatherings.
Comfort is paramount when choosing dress shoes, and the Tinsley-Wingtip does not disappoint. It features a fully cushioned memory foam insole that conforms to your foot's shape, providing superior padded support while effectively absorbing shock. Whether you're on your feet at the office or attending an event, you can expect a level of comfort that rivals many casual shoes.
Durability is another key factor, and the lightweight construction with breathable linings means these shoes are built to last. The flexible sole includes outsole stitch detailing and criss-cross etching that improves traction, ensuring that you feel stable as you walk. However, if you find yourself between sizes, it's recommended to opt for the larger size to ensure a comfortable fit.
In summary, the Stacy Adams Men's Tinsley-Wingtip Oxford stands out for its stylish design, unparalleled comfort, and robust durability. While it may require careful maintenance to preserve the leather finish, the overall value offered by these shoes makes them a smart addition to any footwear collection.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Style | 9/10 | Timeless wing-tip design with elegant details |
| Comfort | 10/10 | Exceptional comfort due to memory foam cushioning |
| Durability | 8/10 | Quality materials ensure longevity |
| Value for Money | 9/10 | Great investment for quality dress shoes |
User Reviews
Ello,Toebox was nothing as expected from other reviews! It was my greatest concern.I was worried id look like a clown! Everything was as expected, perfect for dress shoes.My foot measurement is 11.75in.I tipically wear 12 sneakers/Jordans. Cowboy boots/work boot are 11-11.5 depending on brand, ariats typically run true to size for me!My dress shoes are all 11s, and they seem to almost always fit perfectly!I have a cheap ($35) pair that say 11 but they're more like 14s. They where complete garbage,and still to this day never worn!After that I won't buy dirt cheap shoes.The SA color wasn't as bad as expected, the reviews on the drastic site colors vs what you actually get is spot on! But, it's not super ugly! I guess if, now youre prepared!If it matters that much you can dye them!Toe box was spot on for me! With was great heel felt good and secure. If you get the right size you won't have dumbo feet!The quality of leather I guess is a bit questionable! They are by no means thick super durable leather shoe, but also not paper thin as some reviews I have read. I'm not a fan of the thin glued, fake or real suede inner lining. Would have been nicer with a softer leather trim and thicker suede for the heel and around the ankle. Like it is, it comes off super cheap, half finished, and made short cuts! For as thin and hard as the leather on the shoe was I soaked the lace holes, rim, and stitching in conditioner multiple times then re-buffed! The seem alot more malleable and less chance to crack, crease, or tear.I really can't tell what's fake or real leather on these! It all soaks up the conditioner just like real leather🤷🤷🤷...Another dislike I have is The sole! It's super polished! Zero traction( except on the heel)! I've never in my life had a leather(might be fake(idk)) sole so hard and Polish! I gave a quick walk on the carpet to get a feel and Walk up the stairs and about busted my S@*T!!! Might have to get a wire wheel on that sum bitch, and knock off some of the varnish!!The memory foam heel isn't great and the inner soal is glued in. For that reason these are not gonna be every day shoes! They are way to flat for me to be comfortable for an all day everyday use.I think if you take care of them they should last awhile. On that note it also depends on the person's shoe activities! I have multiple dress pairs as old as 15-20yrs, and Sneakers the same! My daily wears are cowboy and work boots, and it's almost every year they're getting replaced! Those are super thick leather!I'm not disappointed in my buy! I wish I could have waited for a sale instead of full price, but I needed something now, and alil flashy! Two tone wing tips look sexier to me than solid black/brown. I want and will aventually get the blue two tone in this style, but will wait for a sale!Cheers y'all,Hope this helps someone.Zach.
The shoes in the ad photos look brown/dark brown. These shoes are in fact dark cognac with the lighter parts being tan. The combination is a little more flashy than it appears in the ad. The shoes appear to be made of genuine natural leather (not faux). They are polished to a definite shine but not quite as glossy as patent leather. Size 12 fits me a bit loose like size 12s usually do. The underside of the sole measures 13 1/2" from toe to heel and 4 1/2" across at the balls of the feet. The toe is a bit longish but it is also tapered which helps it fit more snug. The shoes came with stiff cardboard cones to help them hold their shape during storage. Both left and right have their own bag with drawstring. I got the size 12 for an amazing price but the shoes are good enough quality that I would pay the full price. I probably will purchase another pair in a different color.UPDATE: I wore the shoes for a few hours to a dinner date and they acquired tiny flexion wrinkles in the uppers as is characteristic of leather shoes. The tiny wrinkles on the tan parts have taken on a slightly lighter tone than the rest of the tan leather. The color effect isn't objectionable but it probably will increase and emphasize the worn look that will take place over time. The wrinkles in the dark brown portions of the shoes have not changed in color at all, they're just tiny wrinkles as would normally be expected.
Love these shoes!!! Look great, feel great!!!
This is a beautiful shoe. However, I returned it as the toe is very pointed that the photos don't really show. I wear a 10.5, medium width... a 10 would have probably fit better. The colors are terrific! Just disappointed in the overly pointed toe.
These striking spectators are exactly what you would expect from a Stacy Adams shoe. I do not work for their company and am a real person. I am a costume designer who looks for unique pieces that will make an impact in a costume and these will do exactly that. Thank you Stacy Adams for building quality, stylish, beautiful pieces that I can count on. The fit is right one, and true to size. My actors feel spoiled when they get to wear your footwear.
I must say that I was skeptical at first, but these shoes are very nice.They have a wood bottom and I love the look of wood bottoms.These are leather so they will be uncomfortable for the first couple wears but will eventually shape to your foot.I was no expected they to be a nice gel heel, so that was a nice suprise.I have been complimented on these shoes more times than I can count.Only issue I have is the front lip of the shoe has came unattached just barely, but I believe this is primarily due to how I walk and how rough I am on shoes.These are daily shoes for me
I love these, and they become a staple of my weekly rotation. I did re-lace them to help with heel slippage and to make them easier to put on and off. I have worn them several times a week for months now. The leather has held up well, and the soles as well. I did add heal taps to prolong their life, and they accepted them just fine as well. Well worth adding to your collection.
Although the shoe looks good, the toe box makes the shoe look like it is a size larger than it is. There is more space in the toe box than I need. In other words, once worn the shoes are going to be too large.