KEEN Utility mens Detroit Xt Low Steel Toe Metatarsal Guard Work Shoe Review
When it comes to work footwear, comfort, safety, and durability are paramount. The KEEN Utility mens Detroit Xt Low Steel Toe Metatarsal Guard Work Shoe in Steel Grey/Bossa Nova delivers all these attributes in spades. With the advanced KEEN.ReGEN cushioning midsole, you can enjoy a remarkable 50% energy return with every step you take. This means whether you're on the job site or performing lighter duties, your feet will not only feel great but also less fatigued.
The shoe is crafted using durable KEEN.Dry waterproof leather, ensuring that your feet stay dry irrespective of the weather conditions. Coupled with a moisture-wicking lining, these shoes provide an optimal climate for your feet throughout the day. Weighing just 25.8 oz / 732 g per shoe, they are surprisingly light given their robust features.
Features
- TOE PROTECTION: Asymmetrical steel toes designed for maximum comfort and unobtrusive fit, exceeding ASTM F2412 and F2413 EH standards.
- TRACTION: Oil- and slip-resistant rubber outsoles that comply with ASTM F1677-96 and F2913 SATRA standards.
- UNDERFOOT PROTECTION: EH-rated footwear acts as a secondary protection source against accidental live electrical circuits contact.
- SUPPORT & COMFORT: KEEN.KEY-TECH FLEX provides contoured underfoot support for enhanced stability and flexibility.
- FOOT PROTECTION: Internal metatarsal guards with lightweight Peron XRD foam that hardens upon impact.
Pros
- Excellent comfort with innovative cushioning technology.
- Effective slip resistance and traction on various surfaces.
- Waterproof design keeps feet dry in wet conditions.
- Durable construction meeting high safety standards.
- Wide fit caters well to those needing additional space.
Cons
- May take some time to break in for optimum comfort.
- Not suitable for heavy-duty tasks requiring more robust footwear.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | KEEN Utility Detroit Xt | Alternative 1: Caterpillar Threshold | Alternative 2: Timberland Pro 6" Pit Boss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toe Protection | Asymmetrical Steel Toes | Steel Toes | Steel Toes |
| Slip Resistance | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Waterproof | Yes | No | Yes |
| Weight (per shoe) | 25.8 oz | 29 oz | 30 oz |
| Metatarsal Guard | Yes | No | No |
Detailed Review
The KEEN Utility mens Detroit Xt Low Steel Toe Metatarsal Guard Work Shoe shines particularly in the area of comfort. Users often rave about the KEEN.ReGEN cushioning midsole, which alleviates the stress associated with long hours on one's feet. The contoured underfoot support and flexible design ensure that you can move freely without sacrificing stability.
From a safety perspective, the asymmetrical steel toes do not compromise comfort while providing necessary protection. Additionally, the oil- and slip-resistant outsole has proven effective even in more challenging environments, successfully tackling spills and slippery areas.
Some users note that breaking them in takes a bit of time, but the payoff in comfort makes it worth it. Moreover, while not suited for heavy-duty jobs, these shoes excel in lighter construction, landscaping, and general maintenance roles, making them versatile.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 4.5/5 | Exceptional cushioning and support, perfect for long shifts. |
| Safety Features | 4.7/5 | Meets high safety standards with steel toes and EH rating. |
| Durability | 4.4/5 | Constructed from quality materials, though may not suit heavy-duty use. |
| Traction | 4.5/5 | Reliable traction on various surfaces, great for workplace hazards. |
User Reviews
I have a wide foot and these are the best fitting keens I’ve bought in the whole 15 years if me buying this brand. They are extremely sturdy and comfortable.
Very comfortable! Love the boots!
The Keen Flint 2 mid steel tip shoe is well made and is close to a true fit. I ordered extra wide but I thought the toes were snug although still comfortable. But my big negative is the weight of the boot. Way too heavy in my opinion. They will be returned.
I wear these to work every day. They take a beating. They are extremely comfortable and supportive as far as work shoes go. Great for demolition or construction. I rest 4x4 lumber on the steel toe while cutting with circular saw. I kick through drywall with these shoes. This is my second pair. First pair lasted two years maybe more. They would have lasted longer except the plastic loops that hold the shoelaces finally broke. But that's pretty good for the kind of beating they take. I use them on weekend hikes as well. Probably should get a pair without the steel to for hiking but I don't really notice. They are the most comfortable shoes I own!
These are excellent quality boots- all the Keen boots I’ve tried are, in my experience. Most fit me perfectly, but this pair felt just a little tight in the toe box, perhaps because of the steel cap. I’m going to try a wide/EE in my usual size, if I can find a store where I can try them on.
On my second set, first lasted about a year and a half doing flooring and mechanic work before showing quite a bit of damage with the sole and around the toe. new set is about 6 months old with no issues so far.
These boots would be nice, comfortable and good looking work boots, but they have a defective problem with the footbed. It feels like there is something in the boot, pull the insole out and the defect can be seen.This footbed defect was seen with not one but also replacement pair. I am returning them. Keen you need to step improve your quality control!
Myself and two other factory coworkers love these boots. Can't go wrong.