KEEN Utility Men's Sparta Low Alloy Toe ESD Work Shoe Review
The KEEN Utility Men's Sparta Low Alloy Toe ESD Work Shoe is specifically designed to meet the rigorous demands of the automotive industry while ensuring maximum comfort and safety. Weighing only 16.8 oz (477 g) per shoe, these low-profile work shoes provide a non-conductive environment, making them ideal for electric-sensitive areas.
Constructed with a breathable mesh and a non-mutilating upper, the Sparta ESD allows for airflow that keeps your feet cool throughout long hours on the job. The innovative KEEN.ReGEN midsole offers all-day comfort by returning energy with every step, providing you a lightweight option that reduces fatigue.
Features
- Alloy Toe: Lightweight aluminum toes that exceed ASTM F2412 and F2413 ESD standards.
- ESD Shock Reduction: Designed to dissipate static electricity, making them perfect for electronics environments.
- Traction: Oil- and slip-resistant rubber outsoles that enhance grip on various surfaces.
- Support & Comfort: KEEN.ReGEN technology ensures superior cushioning and energy return for enhanced comfort.
- Breathable Mesh Upper: Keeps feet cool while preventing damage to sensitive surfaces.
Pros
- Lightweight design minimizes fatigue during long wear.
- Excellent traction with slip-resistant outsoles.
- Effective ESD protection for safe handling of electronic equipment.
- Comfort-focused design with good energy return from the midsole.
- Sleek, non-mutilating upper is suitable for delicate work environments.
Cons
- The removable insole may void ESD safety if replaced.
- Some users may find the fit too wide.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Weight | ESD Protection | Style |
|---|---|---|---|
| KEEN Utility Men's Sparta | 16.8 oz | Yes | Low Top |
| Bates Men's ESD Composite Toe Shoe | 18 oz | Yes | Low Top |
| Caterpillar Men's Second Shift Steel Toe Boot | 22 oz | No | Mid Top |
Detailed Review
The KEEN Utility Men's Sparta Low Alloy Toe ESD Work Shoe stands out in various categories:
- Comfort: With its KEEN.ReGEN technology, this shoe provides exceptional cushioning and energy return. You will appreciate how it alleviates discomfort even after extended wear.
- Safety: These shoes come equipped with alloy safety toes that are significantly lighter than traditional steel toes, without compromising on safety standards. The ESD properties offer additional protection against static discharge, crucial when working around sensitive electronics.
- Durability: Made from high-quality leather and featuring a robust construction, these shoes are built to withstand the rigors of daily use, promising longevity.
- Traction: The specially designed outsoles ensure ample grip on varying surfaces, significantly reducing the risk of slips and falls.
- Breathability: The breathable mesh upper ensures sufficient ventilation, keeping your feet cool, especially in warm conditions.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Outstanding comfort suitable for all-day wear. |
| Safety | 9/10 | High safety standards with effective ESD protection. |
| Durability | 8/10 | Well-constructed for long-lasting use. |
| Traction | 8/10 | Great grip on all surfaces. |
| Breathability | 9/10 | Good ventilation keeps feet cool. |
User Reviews
Great value. Stylish and lightweight. They even have static dissipation if you need that. Feet stay relatively cool compared to similar shoes. By far, the most comfortable steel-toed shoe I've ever worn.
I've been wearing Keen work boots and shoes for 8 years now. I've always cycled between the Detroit low and mid for different seasons, but I wanted something a bit more light and airy for the hot summer where my shop typically hits 90-95 by 3pm. Ugh.Out of the box, they fit and feel pretty much like comfy yet sturdy tennis shoes, like new balances. Obviously they weigh a touch more than regular shoes, but not much. Thankfully I haven't REALLY tested the safety toe on these shoes, however I'm assuming they're just as safe as the ones in the Detroit boots which I tested with having a 280lb engine drop from a faulty cherry picker right onto my foot several years back. Ever since that day, I don't risk regular shoes in the shop.The lace holes look to be reliable, possibly even reinforced which was a gripe I had with the Detroit low shoes and their loops that eventually tear. The included laces are a bit dynamic and stay tight without double knotting which is nice. The mesh outer collects dirt like a magnet, but they blow clean with an air gun easily enough.I like these shoes enough and they're comfortable enough where I wear them outside of work plenty. Big part of the reason I stick with Keens that last 2 years instead of something like Redwing that might last longer at the expense of comfort.
I got these as we have a work requirement for safety toe shoes on those uncommon occasions where I head into the warehouse. I'm usually at my desk doing any number of tasks, so I opted for a lightweight alloy toe shoe-- I figure it's like a foam bike helmet. I still have a pair of leather Keen shoes I bought about 10 years ago, so I figured I would give these a shot.The feel is secure, with a bit of roominess in the toe box. I appreciate shoes that don't squish my toes together, because otherwise I get blistered toes. At the same time it doesn't feel like I'm sliding around in the shoes, they feel secure and comfy. I tend to get arch fatigue after long walks (like at trade shows and conventions), and I don't feel the insoles being particularly supportive there, but I don't plan on going to conventions with these.These claim to be rated for ESD, but I don't have an environment designed to take advantage of that feature, and I still get static zaps unless I'm hooked up to an ESD strap. Maybe if I set up a workstation complete with ESD dissipating floor I'll see how effective these shoes are.One thing I wish was better is breathability. The interior turns into a sauna rather easily, compelling me to pull the shoes off and air them out at least once a day. This might be a thing with safety toe work shoes, but it was a bit of a bummer.
These shoes work great for me and are comfy. I work in a factory and stand for 8 hours and I feel fine after. ESD works fine for me but a couple people who owned these same shoes that I work with had issues with the ESD. Seems to be hit and miss. Still a 5 star from me.
I was looking for a new work shoewith steel toe and waterproofing. I wanted an all purpose shoe because I do a lot of walking and driving. I really like Keen's design, went ahead and bought it even though it lacked a waterproof feature.The shoe has a steel toe feature which is actually light and comfortable. The lack of waterproofing is a bummer... But, its not a deal breaker for these shoes. It does Handel some water but I wouldn't go into deep puddles. The shoes make alot of noise when walking on flat surfaces ( shiny floors, office tiles). It sounds like you just came out from the rain ( still not a deal breaker for me).Overall, I really like the shoes! So nice and comfy and don't regret buying them. So if you want a unique shoe with protection, get this one. But don't step in to big puddles.
The grommet holes that your shoe strings go through come out easily and the string will start to tear the shoe material.If you wear a size 12, I recommend you order a 13. Other than that, it’s a fairly comfortable work shoe.
I work in a warehouse, and I routinely walk 15+ miles a day. All other steel toe shoes I have tried have made my feet hurt whether it's not enough arch, not enough space in the toe box, not enough cushion, or my heels rub raw. These shoes don't do any of that. They are the most comfortable so far. They have just enough cushion that I can walk all day with little discomfort. And they look great too! I have had more comfortable shoes, but not of the safety variety. I would recommend these shoes to anybody that needs a pair with enough comfortability to get you through a long day, with all of the added safety features included. Overall, I would say this shoe gets a 9/10 from me. Maybe just a little bit extra cushion would be nice, but still very doable.
Super light weight. They are cool and fairly breathable. They are comfortable, the insoles have just the right amount of cushion. Will buy again if the last as long as my other Keens.