ECCO Men's ST1 Hybrid Brogue Oxford Review
The ECCO Men's ST1 Hybrid Brogue Oxford in cognac is a perfect blend of traditional style and modern comfort. Made from premium materials, these classic brogue wingtip dress shoes combine relaxed American aesthetics with superior sneaker-like architecture. The result is an exceptional footwear choice that allows you to step into any occasion with confidence.
Features
- Premium Materials: Crafted from rich ECCO leathers and premium suede, ensuring durability and elegance.
- FLUIDFORM Injection Technology: This innovative technology provides anatomical support through a seamless bond between the upper and sole.
- SHOCK THRU Point: Integrated into the TPU outsole, it offers double the shock absorption compared to previous models.
- Removable Insoles: Allows for customization and ease of cleaning.
Pros
- Stylish design suitable for various occasions.
- Exceptional comfort with sneaker-like architecture.
- Durable construction with high-quality materials.
- Excellent shock absorption for all-day wear.
Cons
- May not suit formal environments requiring extremely traditional footwear.
- Initial stiffness may require a break-in period.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Shock Absorption | Insole Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| ECCO Men's ST1 Hybrid Brogue | Leather/Suede | Double | Removable |
| Clarks Tilden Cap Oxford | Leather | Standard | Non-removable |
| Rockport Men’s Classic Penny Loafer | Leather | Standard | Removable |
Detailed Review
When it comes to the ECCO Men's ST1 Hybrid Brogue Oxford, the combination of design and function stands out remarkably. The craftsmanship involved is evident with every step. The premium leather and suede materials not only offer a luxurious look but also ensure longevity.
The FLUIDFORM Injection Technology truly sets these oxfords apart from typical dress shoes. By creating a durable bond without stitching or gluing, it provides users with better anatomical support, allowing for a more natural stride. If you have ever experienced discomfort from traditional dress shoes, this feature could significantly enhance your wearing experience.
Moreover, the SHOCK THRU point does wonders for those long days on your feet. With double the shock absorption compared to earlier designs, your feet will feel cushioned and supported even after hours of wear.
One aspect that some may find challenging is the initial stiffness of the shoe, which can vary depending on how often you wear them. However, many users report that they adapt well over time, making them incredibly comfortable for daily use.
Lastly, the removable insoles are a thoughtful addition, allowing you to customize your fit or replace them with orthotics if necessary. Overall, the ECCO Men's ST1 Hybrid Brogue Oxford is a stylish and versatile footwear option that marries form and function seamlessly.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9.5/10 | Exceptional comfort due to advanced cushioning and support technologies. |
| Style | 9/10 | Classic design that pairs well with both casual and formal attire. |
| Durability | 9/10 | High-quality materials that withstand daily wear and tear. |
| Value for Money | 8/10 | Priced at a premium, but the quality justifies the investment. |
User Reviews
Great fit, true to size. I wear a size 12 in my saucony running shoes and size 46 in these was perfect. Premium looking shoe and good material used, worth the money. I bought the suede as well.
I have searched for a shoe that is not only comfortable but is also slip resistant. I have worn Ecco shoes before and have gotten away from them due to other shoes beating them in comfort. I took these shoes to my restaurant today with a back up pair. My backup pair is now for special events. These shoes are amazing in comfort and non slip on tile surfaces. Didn’t even consider putting in my Johnston and Murphy’s that I paid over $180 for and cannot keep from sliding all over the kitchen floors in. My feet still feel great after a ten hour shift. I did get the magnet color which I am still intrigued with, but a little out of my comfort zone color in a shoe. They still look great and most likely will be better looking after they break in. Leather is durable and I thought I would be covering my ankles in blue bandaids, but never got a blister by the end of the day. Thank you Ecco for a magnificent shoe that finally suits my needs!! I’ve been waiting for you!! This is the first review I have left for a shoe. You really impressed me today!I will purchase other colors in this model for the comfort and slip resistance alone.
I have been buying Ecco shoes for around 20+ years. What keeps bringing back to this brand are several factors: (1) Excellent materials used in construction. (2) Durability, I often get more than 10 years of wear out of a pair of these shoes. (3) The most important feature is their excellent comfort. Not only are they some of the most comfortable shoes I have ever worn, but, they also absorb shock of walking really well. The St1 Hybrid Brogue Oxfords fully meet these three previous factors and add the additional virtue of really great looks. I wear these shoes primarily for business casual dress and I highly recommend them.
This shoe fits great, extremely comfortable and very sturdy. I usually wear Cole Haan and Ecco dress shoes for many years. Cole Haan's are very light and comfortable, however the front of Ecco shoes are wider and put less pressure on the foot. But Ecco's are heavier shoe than CH's. This St1 hybrid is new for me. I needed a dress shoe with good support and comfortable bottom to be able to walk fast for 2 hours a day. I consider it my exercise at work. We have long distance between our buildings and I do not use my car. So far this St1 shoe has been great.
12/12/22:updated review.Good shoe. having warn it for a while now it has softened up. more comfortable now. for foot comfort, it is very comfortable and I can be on it the whole day. I have foot issues so I am very happy with the comfort. good cushioning and my feet have not had much pain being on it all day.initial review:This is an initial review. Got these yesterday. The shoe runs big. I ware a 6.5 US. I went to their website and found their foot measuring chart. Based on the measuring chart it said I would need a 6/6.5. I saw a review that said this runs big so I got the 5/5.5. The length is perfect but the shoe is a little wide so if you have narrow feet you'll have to wear thick socks and lace up tight. Good for winter but not for summer. The shoe lip by the ankles are a little high so it rubs against the base of you angles. Hoping after it gets broken in that it will soften up. The sole of the shoe is good so far. I have foot problems and it seems to be giving good support so far. The shoe laces suck though. It keeps coming undone. really need to change this. Will review again in couple weeks once it is broken in.
I am very impressed with these shoes and think they are totally worth the money.for your size. Order one full size down. I wear a US size 9 in most dress shoes and a 9.5 in running shoes. I ordered the 8-8.5 which is a EU 42 on the tag of the shoe.The shoes are extremely comfortable and appear to be well made. I even liked them so much I ordered a second pair in a different color. Highly recommend.
While the shoe is a bit on the expensive side, it is very comfortable. The leather is probably not as nice as comparable shoes at this price, but the technology of the sole far exceeds your standard leather sole. It is much like walking around in running shoes. This has become my daily wear.
Great work shoe! Looks professional and can walk up to 8-12 miles a day in a 12 hour shift and be comfortable.