ECCO Men's CITYTRAY Cap Toe Tie Oxford Review - Brown (AMBER), Size 9 US Medium
The ECCO Men's CITYTRAY Cap Toe Tie Oxford is a sophisticated choice for anyone seeking a blend of comfort and style. Made using a sleek new European last design, this shoe boasts an elegant toecap complemented by high-quality blind stitching, enhancing its overall silhouette. The shoe is ideal for formal occasions or business settings, ensuring you can stay stylish throughout your day.
Features
- Crafted in full-grain leather from ECCO's own tanneries or premium luxe suede.
- Lined in rich leather for a luxuriously soft feel with textile properties for breathability.
- Reduced-weight sole providing flexibility through innovative ECCO FLUIDFORM Direct Comfort Technology.
- Unique rubber outsole designed with state-of-the-art ECCO TRAY Technology for enhanced stability and grip.
- Removable leather-covered insole for adjustable comfort.
Pros
- High-quality craftsmanship ensures durability.
- Luxurious materials provide a premium feel.
- Comfortable fit suitable for all-day wear.
- Stylish design complements formal attire perfectly.
Cons
- Higher price point compared to some alternatives.
- Limited color options may not suit every style preference.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | ECCO CITYTRAY | Johnston & Murphy Melton | Clarks Tilden Cap Oxford |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Full-grain leather | Calfskin leather | Leather/Suede |
| Closure Type | Lace-Up | Lace-Up | Lace-Up |
| Insole | Removable leather-covered | Padded | Cushioned |
| Technology | FLUIDFORM Direct Comfort | Signature Johnston & Murphy cushioning | Ortholite technology |
Detailed Review
The ECCO Men's CITYTRAY Cap Toe Tie Oxford truly shines in its construction and comfort. The shoe is crafted from premium full-grain leather that immediately conveys a sense of luxury. This material not only looks great but also promises long-lasting wear. The elegant toecap adds a touch of sophistication, making it suitable for both business meetings and formal events.
One of the standout features is the ECCO FLUIDFORM Direct Comfort Technology. This innovation allows for a reduced-weight sole that enhances flexibility while maintaining support. As you navigate through your day, you’ll appreciate the comfort offered by the slightly padded collar and removable insole. These elements work together to create a customized fit that feels almost personal.
Moreover, the unique rubber outsole integrates ECCO TRAY Technology, providing exceptional grip and stability. Whether you're walking on smooth office floors or navigating uneven surfaces, these shoes will keep you grounded and secure.
However, it is worth noting that the price point may be higher than some comparable options on the market. Additionally, the limited color range might not appeal to everyone’s taste. Despite these minor drawbacks, the ECCO CITYTRAY remains an excellent investment for anyone serious about quality footwear.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Design | 9/10 | Sleek and elegant with high-quality craftsmanship. |
| Comfort | 9/10 | Exceptional comfort for all-day wear. |
| Durability | 8/10 | Made from premium materials promising longevity. |
| Value for Money | 7/10 | Higher price but justified by quality. |
User Reviews
Im on my third pair of this shoe. Extremely comfortable but more importantly, the leather and soles last a long time. I am constantly on my feet throughout the day at work, averaging about 10k steps a day or a little over 4.5 miles both inside and outside of the office.
Had to purchase another pair, as the suggested size was wrong, but once the right size came they are very comfortable and perfect for a long day of work in these
Width was fine but the length, including a longer than expected toe box just too long. Guess I would have to purchase a shorter but wider size to get them to fit just right. May be it’s me but had to return. Material seemed acceptable and quality but did not keep them.
This is my 3rd or 4th pair of Ecco men's dress shoes in the last 10+ years. This is my go to brand for work wear, as they make an affordable, stylish, uniform compliant, durable shoe, while being airport friendly.I wear them for long periods of time, 3-5 days a week, and they get a lot of use in all weather conditions.The fit is excellent and the laces have been durable.
Really comfortable for a smart pair of shoes. I normally wear custom insoles for extra arch support but don't need them with these.(Ecco sizing is not aligned with US sizes, and is more aligned with UK sizing. Check the size guide carefully or you'll end up with shoes 1-2 sizes too big like some of the other reviewers).
Won’t buy any other brand. Ecco’s are the most conferrable shoes
I loved the construction and appearance. Unfortunately, they are too narrow at the toe. I had to return them. It would be nice if Ecco offered a wide version of this shoe.
Very comfortable shoes, fits the size.