Carhartt Men's Oxford Black Lightweight Hiker Steeltoe CMO3251 Industrial Boot Review
The Carhartt Men's Oxford Black Lightweight Hiker Steeltoe CMO3251 is not just another work boot; it's a versatile hiking shoe designed for comfort and durability. Ideal for those long days on the trail or running errands around town, these boots incorporate innovations such as Insite Technology to maximize comfort. With a construction featuring a 'No sew' black nylon mesh and premium synthetic upper, paired with a robust cement constructed Carhartt rubber outsole and CMEVA midsole, you can trust that these hikers are made to endure.
Features
- Steel Safety Toe: Protects against impact and compression hazards, meeting ASTM F2413-18 standards.
- Electrical Hazard Rating: Offers secondary protection against incidental contact with electrical circuits of 18,000 volts or less under dry conditions, conforming to ASTM F2413-18 EH standards.
- Insite Technology Footbed: Engineered to provide maximum arch support and reduce foot fatigue during prolonged wear.
- Chemical and Abrasion Resistant: Designed with resistance to oil, chemicals, abrasion, heat, and slips, ensuring performance in harsh environments.
- Quality Construction: Features a PU strobel pad with dual foam Insite Technology footbed.
Pros
- Exceptional comfort thanks to the Insite Technology footbed.
- Durable materials designed to withstand rugged conditions.
- Steel toe protection enhances safety for industrial work.
- Lightweight design suitable for various activities beyond work.
Cons
- Some users may find the steel toe to be snug during extended wear.
- Initial break-in period might require some patience for optimal comfort.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Carhartt CMO3251 | Similar Alternative A | Similar Alternative B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steel Toe | Yes | Yes | No |
| Electrical Hazard Rating | Yes | No | Yes |
| Insite Technology Footbed | Yes | Yes | No |
| Weight | Lightweight | Standard | Heavy |
Detailed Review
With a focus on delivering both style and functionality, the Carhartt Men's Oxford Black Lightweight Hiker Steeltoe CMO3251 excels across several categories. The construction quality stands out, with the combination of durable materials promising longevity and resilience against various working conditions.
Comfort is another cornerstone of this industrial boot, largely attributed to the innovative Insite Technology footbed designed to offer arch support. It's particularly beneficial for those who spend extensive hours on their feet. However, it is worth noting that some users have reported a slight snugness due to the steel toe design, which can require an adjustment period.
The lightweight nature of this boot makes it an excellent option beyond traditional work settings, allowing for versatile use from outdoor adventures to everyday errands. Additionally, the chemical and abrasion-resistant features ensure that you can navigate different environments without worrying about wear and tear.
Lastly, the overall aesthetic appeal combined with practical usage solidifies the Carhartt CMO3251 as a leading choice for anyone needing a reliable hiker capable of handling both professional and personal demands.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Construction Quality | 9/10 | Robust and durable build quality ensuring long-lasting performance. |
| Comfort | 8/10 | Excellent arch support but may require break-in time. |
| Style | 7/10 | Functional yet stylish design suitable for casual wear. |
| Safety Features | 9/10 | Outstanding safety ratings with steel toe and electrical hazard protection. |
User Reviews
Shoe runs small. I’m a 11, but needed a 12. Easy exchange made me happy. Normal ware and tear in warehouse environment and they have held up well. Mesh has torn some, but that is to be expected with how rough I am on them. Tread has held up really well. Fit is comfy for a steel toe. Does rub side of my big toe some, but I haven’t found a steel toe that doesn’t. Comfy padding. I’m on feet all day and these support me decently. Really glad I had steel toes when pallets land on my feet!
They are far heavier than they look.Comfort and quality seem to be standard with Carhartt. Super cool in my opinion.Got mine thru open box for $60.They are holding up to the work load so far.I am a truck driver
Was looking for a low rise boot for work. This is definitely a well made boot, the only problem is the weight. These are VERY heavy. After an hour of wearing them, you feel as though you've completed a workout. Otherwise, they are comfortable, well fitting and generally a good boot.
I bought a wide width pair of Skechers to compare with this wide width pair of Carhartt black slip resistant work shoes I bought. The Carhartt shoes win hands down. No contest. The Carhartt shoes are more comfortable and are better for long distance walking, despite the extra weight in the toes from the steel toes. The Skechers made my heel hurt while walking and don't fit as well.The black Skechers slip resistant standard width shoes I bought last year had a one piece sole, like the Carhartt work shoes I bought this year with the new pair of Skechers. The plastic label on the top of the standard width shoes is white instead of yellow, and the shoes are comfortable. I've hiked many times in the standard width Skechers and washed the shoes in a wash machine and the shoes are still in good condition. The new wide Skechers have a multi piece sole, which is similar to the last pair of white Skechers I bought. The soles on those white Skechers fell apart as soon as I started walking on them. I won't buy another white pair of white Skechers or another pair of wide width black work Skechers. 2/3 of the Skechers I've bought in the last 2 years have been junk. Skechers used to make shoes I liked.
I'm on my feet in a garage for about 10 hours/day and these are a good shoe for it. I stomped through the first few weeks in my old work boots and these are far superior for the indoor working environment. The steel toes provide excellent protection, the outsoles are thick and tough, and the general design is without extra flaps of material to get caught on things so I'm never hung up on anything in that way. I wouldn't run through an oil spill, but the traction is pretty good otherwise. The slight heel is nice and gives them that boot like feeling without the heavy over coverage and extra weight if your environment doesn't demand that kind of ankle support.
Bought in April used em for 5 months the boot is already separating
Love the look and get alot of compliments, but don't last lone in a real construction environment.
I’m a big guy and they are really comfortable. This is my second pair. My first pair lasted a year. The durability of the shoe was great but the cushion eventually wore out. I would definitely buy for a third time.