Calvin Klein Men's Brodie Oxford, Black Saffiano, 11 Review
If you're searching for a dress shoe that combines elegance with comfort, the Calvin Klein Men's Brodie Oxford in Black Saffiano is a remarkable contender. With its sleek lines and fashionable tapered toe, this shoe embodies a handsome appeal that suits both professional and casual looks.
Related Products
Features
- Material: Soft nappa leather for a luxurious feel
- Closure: Lace-up design ensures a secure fit
- Construction: Derby style promotes breathability and flexibility
- Toe Shape: Rounded square toe adds a contemporary touch
- Comfort: Lightly cushioned foam insole enhancing comfort and shock absorption
- Fit: Available in extended sizes and widths (14M-16M and 7W-16W)
- Care Instructions: Machine washable for easy maintenance
Pros
- Stylish and modern design
- Flexible construction for ease of movement
- Lightweight cushioning provides exceptional comfort
- Variety of size and width options for an optimal fit
Cons
- Higher price point compared to some competitors
- May require a break-in period for maximum comfort
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Calvin Klein Men's Brodie Oxford | Similar Alternative: Cole Haan Original Grand |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Soft Nappa Leather | Leather Upper |
| Comfort | Lightly Cushioned Foam Insole | Cushioning insole for support |
| Style | Derby Construction | Oxford Style |
| Sizing Options | Extended Sizes and Widths | Standard Sizes Only |
Detailed Review
The Calvin Klein Men's Brodie Oxford stands out in the crowded space of men's dress shoes, thanks to its exceptional combination of style, comfort, and versatility. Let's break down the aspects that make this shoe a worthwhile investment.
Style: The sleek lines and tapered toe create an eye-catching silhouette that complements any outfit, whether you choose to pair it with formal Calvin Klein suiting or opt for a more dressed-down look with denim. The chic black saffiano leather brings a modern twist to classic styling.
Comfort: Comfort is key when it comes to footwear, and the Brodie Oxford doesn't disappoint. The flexible construction allows for easy movement, while the lightly cushioned foam insole absorbs shocks and keeps your feet feeling fresh throughout the day. This makes them suitable not just for workdays but also special occasions where you might find yourself on your feet longer than expected.
Fit: Achieving the perfect fit can often be a challenge, but the Brodie Oxford offers a range of extended sizes and widths. This inclusive sizing approach means that finding your ideal fit is more attainable, helping to alleviate discomfort that can arise from ill-fitting shoes.
Maintenance: One of the practical advantages of these shoes is their care instructions; being machine washable makes upkeep straightforward and hassle-free. You won't have to worry about painstaking cleaning routines.
In conclusion, if you're looking for a dress shoe that offers a fusion of aesthetics and comfort, the Calvin Klein Men's Brodie Oxford is worth considering. Its stylish design, adaptable comfort levels, and availability in various sizes make it a solid choice for any man's wardrobe.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Style | 9/10 | Modern and stylish design, versatile for many occasions. |
| Comfort | 8/10 | Lightly cushioned and flexible, though may need breaking in. |
| Fit | 9/10 | Wide range of sizes available for a comfortable fit. |
| Value for Money | 7/10 | Higher price point, but quality justifies the investment. |
User Reviews
I was worried about the sizing on this shoe after reading some of the reviews, but this fits true to size. I wear a 10.5 US on all my other shoes, and this fit perfectly. The extra space referred to by another reviewer at the toe is by design. They don't look like clown shoes. My foot is a bit wide and this shoe accommodates that perfectly. The leather is soft and supple right out of the box. The sole is also soft and quiet on the floor. This was a concern as I have a pair of CK derby style shoes that sound like wooden clogs when I walk on my hardwood floor with them. These are much more quiet. I'm not a fan of people being able to hear me coming from down the hall, so these shoes are great in that sense. The perforated leather looks good with chinos or with a suit. They give texture to your overall outfit.There is a bit of discomfort at the top of the upper where the tongue and laces meet on the right foot, but that has already begun to lessen as they break in after a few days' wear. BTW there was very little "break-in" time needed as they were comfortable in all day wear situations from the first day.
Beautiful, dark brown, plain toe derbies. I was specifically looking for a nice set of brown shoes that stayed away from the more orangey shade of brown that dominates the market these days. I like that color, but it does not always match the suits I wear. This pair definitely achieved that end. Very comfortable shoes. Maybe a little tight in the toe box, but didn't feel overly tight. I wear a 10 or a 10 wide depending on the shoe and I was able to fit comfortably in the standard 10 for this shoe. Overall I would definitely recommend them.
You can’t go wrong with shiny shoes with pointed toes. These give you that classic expensive look and fit well.
The Calvin Klein Men's Brodie Burnished Dress Calf Oxford in black is a stylish and comfortable shoe. Made of high-quality leather, this shoe is both durable and elegant. The burnished finish adds a touch of sophistication, making it perfect for formal occasions.
I wear an 8.5 in Nike and 7.5 in Calvin Klein. I chose to order these shoes in 7.5 and fit good. Now, it will start a little tight because I do wear wide. Since these are lace-up shoes, the tightness will also depend on the type of socks that you wear. Great purchase and a great price point.
The following applies to the first week of purchase/wear:Out of the box, these shoes look exactly like the photos, though they aren't as shiny as you may expect. That is very easily remedied though, if you use a bit of shoe polish. I had best results with Meltonian branded polish/cream.The laces do not appear to be leather, which doesn't bother me and is just a call out for those who find this important. The eyelets for the laces are reinforced with a little metal rivet thing on the underside. Some shoes don't have this feature and their eyelets will deform, so it was a pleasant surprise to find this feature.The leather for the shoe is pretty stiff, but that's out of the box. It should break in as I wear it more. I will follow up with additional comments.The fit for me was excellent and is comfortable, though it is a bit lacking in terms of cushioning and arch support.
My husband could not wait to get these shoes! He loved them. He liked them because they were not shiny and felt that he could use these as "everyday" wear. He is on his feet ALL DAY so comfort is a big must for him. My husband is very particular when it comes to comfort and wear ability.Pros: Very pleased with the design on the shoe and the mute color tone. Fit was pretty perfect, maybe a slight small. Not even a half size. The package was delivered very fast. Good insole and nice point to the toe. Comfortable for a couple hours. Not too pointy. Easy return!Cons: The shoes rubbed the back of his heel and ended up causing blisters. A big no-no for my husband.For my husband these were not the shoe for him since he is constantly on his feet and walking around a HUGE hospital. This shoe should be good for a couple of hours of wear, but would not recommend for long days on your feet. Overall, they are beautiful shoes and we were disappointed they did not work out. I hope if you decided to buy these shoes they work out for you! By the way my husband wears a Size 10, narrow, flat foot.