Allen Edmonds Mens Plymouth Walnut Monk Straps Review
The Allen Edmonds Mens Plymouth Walnut Monk Straps are a standout choice for those looking to elevate their formal wardrobe. With a plain-toe single monk strap design, these shoes seamlessly transition from business meetings to casual outings. The classic fit is true to size, ensuring that you won’t have to worry about uncomfortable pinching or slipping while walking.
Handcrafted in Port Washington, WI, these shoes utilize premium European calfskin leather, showcasing a rich walnut finish that complements various attire. Additionally, the soft tan leather lining provides an extra layer of comfort, making them suitable for extended wear.
Related Products
Features
- 360º bench welt construction for durability and stability
- Custom Cork Insole that adapts for a personalized fit
- Single oak leather sole enhancing flexibility and traction
- Handcrafted using fine imported leathers
- Built on the 201 last for optimal shape and fit
- Recraftable design, extending the life of your investment
Pros
- Exceptional craftsmanship with high-quality materials
- Versatile style suited for both formal and casual attire
- Customizable comfort due to cork insole
- Durable build ensuring longevity
- Made in the USA, supporting local craftsmanship
Cons
- Price point may be higher than other brands
- Initial break-in period required for maximum comfort
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Sole Type | Closure Type | Recraftable |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allen Edmonds Mens Plymouth Walnut Monk Straps | Premium European Calfskin Leather | Leather | Pull-On | Yes |
| Brogue Monkey Men's Monk Strap Shoes | Genuine Leather | Rubber | Double Monk | No |
| Sperry Top-Sider Men's Leather Dress Shoe | Full Grain Leather | TPR | Slip-On | No |
Detailed Review
When considering comfort, the Plymouth Walnut Monk Straps stand out with their custom cork insole that molds to the shape of your foot. This feature provides an unparalleled level of comfort that’s hard to find in other dress shoes. You'll appreciate the supportive feel as you stride through your day.
In terms of style, these shoes are incredibly versatile. Their sleek design pairs well with suits for a formal look or can be dressed down with chinos for a smart-casual vibe. The walnut color adds a touch of sophistication, making it easier to match with different outfits.
The durability aspect is highlighted by the 360º bench welt construction, allowing for long-lasting wear without compromising on comfort. The handcrafted nature means each pair is made with care, which reflects in their performance over time.
However, potential buyers should be aware of the initial break-in period. While these shoes eventually offer superior comfort, the first few wears may require some adjustment as the leather softens.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Excellent cushioning and support with a moldable insole. |
| Style | 10/10 | Timeless and versatile design perfect for multiple occasions. |
| Durability | 9/10 | Sturdy construction ensures long-lasting use. |
| Value for Money | 8/10 | Higher price point but justified by quality and recraftability. |
| Fit | 8/10 | True to size, however, break-in required for optimal fit. |
User Reviews
As expected from AE, excellent craftsmanship and they look very stylish. Slim appearance but not too narrow in the foot bed. Highly recommend for a long lasting great quality dress shoe.
These are nicely designed shoes . These run larger than normal . Sole isn’t great and is wearing out fast
Take a look at the pictures I posted.The bad: I received the shoes with a tear in the leather of the left shoot where the stitching comes together. I noticed it out of the box but didn't know what it was until I went to a local shoe cobbler. She asked if the shoes were a "factory second" and if I paid full retail price. I told her I did pay full retail and she said that it wasn't acceptable.More bad: The right heel counter is appropriately 1 cm high than the left. It caused pain from day one. I tried to break it in, did everything recommended on the Allen Edmonds website and then noticed this issue.The last bad: See my last picture, the stitching is coming out of the left shoe and a tear in the leather on the side was noticed. I wear overshoes, I work in an office building. I've never seen such a thing and I've only worn cheaper dress shoes with worse leather.The good: The left shoe was comfortable and seemed to fit well from day one. Besides the above issues, they seemed to be good quality otherwise.Unfortunately, I am going to return them. This was my first purchase of a high quality shoe and I am disappointed. I read much about how a higher quality shoe could last a decade or longer. Mine lasted a couple of weeks. Back to cheaper shoes for me.
I've wanted a pair of Allen Edmond shoes for 7 years. I was so excited when I got home to check out my new shoes! ...and you can see the pics for yourself. And there are problems with both of them.Inside sole isn't even attached in one of them! Cuts in the heels and leather. Staining in the leather (and not just normal stain variation). The stitching is messy in many places. Frayed leather... In short, I'm absolutely convinced they sold me a poorly executed, refurbished pair of shoes.(Not relevant to you guys) But if AE somehow sees this, just wanted to personally thank you for being the cherry on top of a day I already grieve on.