Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Oxford, Walnut, 12 D US Review
The Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Oxford is a remarkable blend of traditional craftsmanship and contemporary style. This shoe pays homage to the classic monk strap, initially designed as a sturdier alternative to the sandals worn by monks throughout Europe. The evolution of this style has culminated in the creation of the St. John's, a double monk strap shoe that seamlessly integrates a cap toe with exquisite perfing and pinking details along the toe and waist.
In terms of formality, the St. John's strikes an impressive balance, sitting comfortably between a balmoral and blucher style. This versatility means you can pair it with a tailored suit for formal occasions or dress down with jeans for a more casual yet polished look.
Features
- Cap toe shoes with stylish perforated brogue detailing
- Lined with premium leather upper for durability
- Single leather oak sole for longevity
- 360-degree Goodyear welted construction ensuring quality
- Manufactured in the USA
- Caring tips: Use Allen Edmonds Leather Lotion for maintenance and premium shoe polish for luster
Pros
- Versatile design suitable for various occasions
- Durable construction enhances longevity
- Classic aesthetic with modern touches
- Premium materials ensure comfort and support
Cons
- May require a break-in period for optimal comfort
- Higher price point compared to some alternatives
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Allen Edmonds St. John's Oxford | Johnston & Murphy Conard Double Monk | Brogue Wings Monk Strap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | 100% Leather | Leather and synthetic blend | Genuine leather |
| Construction | Goodyear welted | Blake stitched | Goodyear welted |
| Origin | Made in USA | Made in India | Made in Italy |
| Sole Type | Single leather oak sole | Rubber sole | Leather sole |
Detailed Review
Style and Design: The design of the Allen Edmonds St. John's Oxford is striking, embodying both elegance and sophistication. The cap toe and brogue detailing provide a classic vibe, making it a standout choice for any wardrobe.
Comfort: Upon wearing, many users have reported that while the shoes may feel stiff initially, they mold to the foot after a short break-in period. The soft leather lining contributes significantly to overall comfort.
Durability: Crafted with premium materials and sturdy Goodyear welt construction, these shoes are built to last. The single leather oak sole not only adds to their aesthetic but also promises longevity.
Care and Maintenance: Proper care is essential to maintain the shoes' appearance and prolong their life. Using Allen Edmonds Leather Lotion and their Premium Shoe Polish can help keep them looking their best.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Style | 9/10 | Classic yet contemporary design perfect for diverse occasions. |
| Comfort | 8/10 | Initial stiffness gives way to comfort after break-in. |
| Durability | 9/10 | High-quality materials and construction ensure long-lasting wear. |
| Value for Money | 7/10 | While an investment, the quality justifies the price. |
User Reviews
Great shoes, these are really nice, I do not recommend the lower-end Allen Edmonds but any of the leather soles - $400 and up shoes are worth it.
Shoes are perfect, fit the way they should.
Nice well made shoes but they seem to run large.
I ordered a Allen Edmonds St. Johns, Chili, size 8.5. I receive an Allan Edmonds' box and travel bags for each shoes BUT the shoes are UV SIGNATURE brand!! and size 9!! A TOTAL SCAM. Not Recommended, Its better to buy it in the original website.
Great shoes.. I didn't have the problem with the Squeaking the guy said from the last review.. You should try to get with customers service from Allen emdonds there really great company .. I have gotten a lot of compliments from the lady's 😉
several defects
I bought these in a 10.5 E, which has always been a perfect fit for me with AE. I could barely get my foot in these. Be warned that these have a much more "modern" toe box that is extremely narrow.Mine lacked any major defects or issues, but it's still evident that Allen Edmonds quality is nowhere near where it was in yesteryear. Everything is just a bit sloppier now. They simply lack the attention to detail one would expect with $400 shoes.