Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Oxford Review
The Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Oxford in Walnut is a sophisticated twist on the classic monk strap shoe, originally designed for durability and style. This modern interpretation features exquisite detailing such as perfing and pinking along the cap toe, making it not only stylish but also versatile enough for various occasions.
This double monk strap shoe sits comfortably between formal and casual wear, allowing you to seamlessly pair it with a suit or your favorite jeans. The craftsmanship reflects quality, with premium leathers and traditional construction methods that ensure longevity and comfort with every step.
Related Products
Features
- Cap toe shoes with perforated brogue styling
- Lined premium leather upper for added comfort
- Single leather oak sole that enhances durability
- 360-degree Goodyear welted construction ensuring a secure fit
- Made in the USA, reflecting superior craftsmanship
- Care Instructions: Use Allen Edmonds Leather Lotion and Premium Shoe Polish for maintenance
Pros
- Exceptional craftsmanship with high-quality materials
- Versatile design suitable for multiple occasions
- Comfortable fit due to premium leather lining
- Stylish detailing adds a contemporary touch
- Durable construction ensures longevity
Cons
- Premium price point may not be accessible for all
- Requires proper care to maintain appearance
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Allen Edmonds St. John's Oxford | Other Brands' Monk Straps |
|---|---|---|
| Material | 100% Leather | Varies by brand |
| Sole Type | Leather | Rubber or Leather depending on brand |
| Made In | USA | Various countries |
| Construction | 360-degree Goodyear welted | Varies by brand |
Detailed Review
The Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Oxford sets a benchmark in the world of dress shoes. The attention to detail is immediately apparent with its elegant cap toe and the refined brogue styling that gives it a unique character. These shoes transition effortlessly from a day at the office to an evening out, providing versatility without compromising on style.
In terms of comfort, you'll appreciate the lined premium leather upper which cushions your foot while maintaining breathability. The single leather oak sole not only looks classy but also provides excellent support. With the 360-degree Goodyear welted construction, these shoes are built to last, making them a worthy investment for anyone looking to elevate their footwear collection.
However, it's worth noting that this level of quality comes with a price. The initial cost might seem steep, but considering the craftsmanship and longevity of the product, it proves to be a valuable addition to your wardrobe.
Proper care is crucial; using Allen Edmonds Leather Lotion will help maintain the supple texture of the calfskin, while regular polishing keeps the luster intact. If you're someone who appreciates fine shoes and the history behind them, the Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Oxford is undoubtedly a model worth considering.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Design | 9/10 | Classic yet contemporary styling with distinctive details. |
| Comfort | 8/10 | Premium leather lining offers comfort but may require break-in time. |
| Durability | 10/10 | High-quality materials ensure long-lasting wear and resilience. |
| Value for Money | 7/10 | Higher price point justified by craftsmanship and longevity. |
User Reviews
Great shoes, these are really nice, I do not recommend the lower-end Allen Edmonds but any of the leather soles - $400 and up shoes are worth it.
Shoes are perfect, fit the way they should.
Nice well made shoes but they seem to run large.
I ordered a Allen Edmonds St. Johns, Chili, size 8.5. I receive an Allan Edmonds' box and travel bags for each shoes BUT the shoes are UV SIGNATURE brand!! and size 9!! A TOTAL SCAM. Not Recommended, Its better to buy it in the original website.
Great shoes.. I didn't have the problem with the Squeaking the guy said from the last review.. You should try to get with customers service from Allen emdonds there really great company .. I have gotten a lot of compliments from the lady's 😉
I bought these in a 10.5 E, which has always been a perfect fit for me with AE. I could barely get my foot in these. Be warned that these have a much more "modern" toe box that is extremely narrow.Mine lacked any major defects or issues, but it's still evident that Allen Edmonds quality is nowhere near where it was in yesteryear. Everything is just a bit sloppier now. They simply lack the attention to detail one would expect with $400 shoes.
several defects