Irish Setter Marshall Men’s 11" Waterproof Soft Toe Pull-On Work Boot Review
The Irish Setter Marshall Men’s 11" Waterproof Soft Toe Pull-On Work Boot is designed for those who need a reliable work boot that can withstand tough environments while providing ultimate comfort. Crafted from 100% full-grain waterproof leather, these boots ensure your feet stay dry and protected throughout the day.
With an impressive construction quality, the boots meet ASTM safety standards, including ASTM F2892-18 for electrical hazards, making them suitable for various hazardous workplaces. The slip, heat, and electrical hazard-resistant properties mean that you can focus on the task at hand without worrying about your footwear.
Related Products
Features
- Meets ASTM Safety Standards: Designed to resist slips, heat, and electrical hazards.
- Soft Toe Design: Offers protection against workplace hazards.
- Comfortable & Durable: Equipped with a removable polyurethane footbed and steel shank for added stability.
- Waterproof Design: UltraDry waterproof construction keeps your feet dry in wet conditions.
- Platform Construction: Goodyear Welt construction enhances durability and allows resoling.
Pros
- Extremely comfortable even during extended wear.
- Excellent waterproof protection.
- Durable construction ensures longevity.
- Meets high safety standards for various work environments.
- Lightweight design thanks to RPM technology.
Cons
- Initial break-in period may be required for optimal comfort.
- Limited color options available.
- Not as stylish for casual wear compared to other options.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Irish Setter Marshall | Thorogood American Heritage | Carhartt 10" Waterproof Boot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waterproof | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Safety Standards | ASTM F2892-18, EH | ASTM F2413-18 | ASTM F2413-18 |
| Soft Toe | Yes | Yes | No |
| Weight Reduction Technology | RPM Technology | No | No |
| Removable Footbed | Yes | No | Yes |
Detailed Review
The Irish Setter Marshall Men’s Work Boot excels in the realm of comfort and utility. The removable polyurethane footbed provides cushioning that adapts to your foot shape, making long hours on the job much more bearable. Furthermore, the addition of a steel shank in the midsole acts as a supportive fortress, ensuring that you can tackle uneven terrain without discomfort.
When it comes to protection, the soft toe design means that while it does not offer the heavy-duty protection of a steel toe, it still covers essential safety guidelines, making it suitable for various light to moderate work settings. The boots also feature Goodyear Welt construction, which not only increases strength but also allows for easy resoling, extending the lifespan of your investment significantly.
In terms of waterproofing, the UltraDry technology effectively manages moisture and keeps your feet dry, which is especially crucial if you are in an environment prone to spills or weather changes. This moisture barrier combined with the breathable lining prevents sweat build-up, offering all-day comfort.
On the downside, the initial break-in period may require some time to adjust, as is common with many durable work boots. However, this slight inconvenience is outweighed by the overall benefits of comfort, support, and safety that the Irish Setter Marshall offers.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Exceptional cushioning and support, though needs break-in time. |
| Durability | 8/10 | High-quality materials and construction offer great longevity. |
| Waterproofing | 9/10 | Effectively keeps feet dry in wet conditions. |
| Safety | 8/10 | Meets industry standards; soft toe may not suit all job requirements. |
| Value for Money | 9/10 | Good investment for serious workers needing reliability and comfort. |
User Reviews
Comfortable, sturdy, look and feel great!
Only worn a few times but they felt good as soon as I put onI especially like the top of the boots because they are much softer than other brands, not so stiff around the lower calvesThey are a nice looking two tone color leatherI will say the insoles are far cheaper than what comes in Ariat brand boots. I took a pair from my never worn Ariat boots and ordered a replacement today. The insoles in these are thin and weak especially the toe area.I hope the boots wear well. I usually only buy Ariat but bought these because they look great and are waterproof plus I caught an incredible sale price for $169
They are a gift for my grandson and these are the only boot he'll wear for work or everyday. Get him new ones every year. Great buy. The always look great andwear well. .
Fit is spot on to any other cowboy boot. They will be tight at first but will break in quickly. Not as comfortable as I was expecting from Irish Setter boots. They are not bad, just not as I was expecting and not as good as some reviews I read. Don't hold your expectation at a level like you are walking on clouds. Overall the boot will be great as a weekend work boot with occasional mud and water exposure. I have worn through lots of mud and washed them off and feet stay dry, I love that about them. After a long day of working you are will feel sore feet.
Bought these for my husband for Christmas. He loves them so much and are comfy. He wears them every day.
Received boots quickly. These boots are well made. Great fit and last a long long time.
Perfect fit 5’10’ 275