Irish Setter, Ely, Men's 6" Soft Toe Work Boot Review
The Irish Setter Ely Men's 6" Soft Toe Work Boot combines a rich tradition of craftsmanship with modern safety and comfort features. First introduced in 1950 by Red Wing Shoes, this boot has stood the test of time, proving itself as a reliable choice for both hardworking professionals and outdoor enthusiasts alike.
Crafted from high-quality Red Russet leather, the Ely is designed not only for durability but also for performance in demanding environments. Whether you're on a construction site or out hunting, this boot holds true to the Irish Setter legacy of superior footwear.
Related Products
Features
- Meets ASTM Safety Standards: Offers electrical hazard resistance per ASTM F2892-18, EH standards.
- Soft Toe: Provides essential protection against workplace hazards.
- Durable & Long Lasting: Direct attach construction ensures a watertight bond and flexibility.
- All-Day Performance: Features a removable polyurethane footbed for enhanced underfoot comfort.
- Reliable Traction: PU V-Grip outsole provides excellent ground traction and shock absorption.
Pros
- High-quality, durable full grain leather upper.
- Comfortable for long hours due to supportive design.
- Lightweight construction enhances wearability.
- Excellent traction for varied work conditions.
Cons
- May require a break-in period for optimal comfort.
- Soft toe may not provide sufficient protection for certain heavy-duty tasks.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Irish Setter Ely Men's Work Boot | Alternative A (e.g., Wolverine Durashocks) | Alternative B (e.g., Timberland PRO 6") |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | 100% Leather | Leather/Synthetic | Premium Full Grain Leather |
| Safety Standard | ASTM F2892-18, EH | ASTM F2413-18 | ASTM F2413-18 |
| Weight | Lightweight | Moderate | Heavy |
| Footbed | Removable Polyurethane | Memory Foam | Anti-Fatigue Technology |
Detailed Review
Build Quality
The Irish Setter Ely is built to last, utilizing a direct attach construction method that eliminates the need for glue or stitching, providing a strong, watertight bond. This level of craftsmanship speaks volumes about its durability, making it suitable for both tough job sites and rugged outdoor activities.
Comfort
With its cushioned polyurethane footbed, you can expect all-day comfort while wearing these boots. The non-metallic composite shank adds support to your feet, enhancing stability. Although some users might experience a slight break-in discomfort, this quickly dissipates to reveal a comfortable fit.
Performance
Designed for everyday use, the PU V-Grip outsole offers impressive traction and flexibility, making it ideal for various terrains. Whether you are navigating slippery surfaces at work or uneven ground during a hike, the Ely boot will keep you balanced and secure.
Style
Not only functional, but the Red Russet leather gives the Ely boot a classic look that pairs well with work attire or casual outfits. Its aesthetic appeal makes it versatile for different settings.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Durability | 9/10 | Built to withstand severe conditions with high-quality materials. |
| Comfort | 8/10 | Good cushioning with a slight break-in period required. |
| Traction | 9/10 | Excellent grip for various terrains; reliable performance. |
| Value for Money | 8/10 | Competitive pricing considering the quality and performance offered. |
User Reviews
They fit and feel great. 40 years on my feet have made them sensitive ti shoes. These are pretty good. Even though they are soft toe there is some kind of plastic insert in the toe, so they still have the look of steel toe boots. These are pretty good for maintenance but they are not heavy duty. There's almost no cushion had to buy additional insoles.
*Going on two years of constant wear in all weather through horse manure, mud, intense salt water and crude oil. I don't take care of my boots,I just wear them. Very little sole wear but short of shale I'm rarely on concrete.Schools still attached like new. The side seams have partially split BUT I was born with underformed ankles, I am considered partially handicapped lol...Anyhow, I'm rather unstable, even with custom insoles, wide feet and I lean. The outer seam on one boot and inner seam of the other makng it obvious this is due to my stance, insults and abuse. The lining is still in tact. But I can lace these up tight and do a days work. I'm only back because the laces have worn, not broken...Kevlar strand is still hanging in..Excellent work boot. On and off fast, lightweight and very comfortable. Comes with very fine but strong laces. Being as small as string, they don't cut into your hand but don't grip the eyelets while tying, which allows for easy on and off. I agree with another reviewer that one boot cuff was rough on my calf...at first. If you are use to wearing a full boot, tie these a little loose at first and your calf will adjust quickly. They were cheaper even I bought them but I will buy them again.
My go too boot maker, I knew they would be comfortable and be made with out any defects.
good construction, however it is 1/2 size oversized. trust me. been a 9 boot size all my life, should have gone 8 1/2. but will not bother to return. the sole is bonded to upper. once it delaminates, the boot is history. sadly, most boot construction is that way today. overall, better than competition. but go 1/2 size down, you won't be sorry
A little big, but a good pair of socks and they're great!
I was so excited to give these to my husband for his birthday, epic fail! These claim to be soft toe and they definitely are NOT! They are steel toe, as described on the box! So totally disappointed , as his gift can not be worn and now I am inconvenienced and have to send these back! 😡
Great deal on quality shoes.
I got these for my boyfriend who works in landscaping his had this for about a year he these are his daily boots and have maintained very well. Great for the winter time slip resistant and waterproof very comfortable after you break it in!