Eastland Women's Holly Penny Loafer Review
The Eastland Women's Holly Penny Loafer in Black is more than just a stylish footwear choice; it's a perfect blend of traditional design and modern comfort. This penny loafer showcases a classic silhouette that appeals to both timeless fashion enthusiasts and those seeking everyday practicality.
Featuring a synthetic upper with a fabric lining, these loafers are designed to conform to your foot for that much-desired custom fit. The elevated sole not only enhances its aesthetic appeal but also provides added height without compromising on comfort.
Related Products
Features
- Synthetic upper for durability
- Memory foam insole that conforms to your foot's curves
- Textured rubber outsole for excellent slip resistance and durability
- Heel Height: 1 3/4 inches
- Imported craftsmanship
Pros
- Classic style suitable for various occasions
- Exceptional comfort due to memory foam insole
- Great slip-resistance from the rubber outsole
- Lightweight construction makes them easy to wear
Cons
- Available only in limited colors
- May require a break-in period for some users
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Eastland Women's Holly | Clarks Women's Editha | Dr. Scholl's Women’s Madison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upper Material | Synthetic | Leather | Fabric |
| Insole | Memory Foam | Ortholite | Gel Cushioning |
| Outsole | Rubber | EVA | Rubber |
| Heel Height | 1 3/4 inches | 2 inches | 1 inch |
Detailed Review
When it comes to selecting the right loafers, comfort should be at the forefront of your mind, and the Eastland Women's Holly Penny Loafer excels in this department. The memory foam insole is particularly noteworthy, as it cradles your feet throughout the day, providing a level of support that helps reduce fatigue during long hours of wear.
The synthetic upper is impressively soft, making it comfortable against your skin while still maintaining a polished look appropriate for both casual outings and more formal settings. Its classic penny loafer profile ensures versatility; whether you pair it with jeans or dress pants, you'll always look well put together.
On the practical side, the rubber outsole offers excellent traction, making these loafers suitable even for slightly wet conditions. You can confidently stride through different terrains without worrying about slips or falls.
However, it is worth noting that the Eastland Women's Holly Penny Loafer may require a brief break-in period for optimal comfort. Users may also find the color options somewhat limited compared to other brands, which is something to consider if you're looking for variety.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 5/5 | Exceptional cushioning with memory foam insole |
| Style | 4/5 | Classic design that suits multiple occasions |
| Durability | 4/5 | High-quality synthetic upper and rubber outsole |
| Value for Money | 4/5 | Offers good comfort and style for the price |
User Reviews
Trust to size. I'm a size 10. Sometimes I need wides but these fit well. I love the chunky heel so that I can wear my longer non hemmed pants. I can't wear full heels anymore but these give me a little height which I love. Very sturdy shoe. O wear them 3x a week with business attire. I've had many compliments on them. They are very comfortable and no pinching in the toe box which can sometimes be an issue fir me. I may come back and purchase the brown ones.
I have already gotten compliments on these shoes. They fit well and are great for the price.
These shoes are very pretty and look good on your feet. The footbed is very comfortable but the back that goes across your Achilles tendon tends to rub because it's very stiff. I would suggest ordering a half size up so you can wear thicker socks or put a Band-Aid across your tendon. They are well made other than that.
Bit snug when first put on, but loosened up during first wear. I’m a restaurant manager and wore them for full 11 hour shift first day (I had brought another pair to change into for break in period & didn’t need them) enough traction that no issues in wet areas like dish room or behind bar. Received compliments every time I wear them. Plan to order in different colors as it’s difficult to find shoes that are nonslip, cute and professional looking
I have gotten compliments on these shoes. They look great and work with almost any outfit, but they are pinchy especially across the wides part of my feet (I do not usually wear wide shoes), and the arch support is very minimal. Not super comfortable. If I purchase again, I would buy wides and get some arch support inserts.
Extremely comfortable walking shoes. Great quality
I read that this shoe runs small so I sized up. Nope, still to tight. I have average sized feet, no narrow or wide. Just average. Still a whole size up was so tight I wouldn't have been able to wear socks.
They are cheap plastic not like the Eastlanders I have had in the past and no green tag on the outside seam Very disappointing so I’m returning them.