Dr. Scholl's Shoes Women's Brilliance Wide Calf Riding Boot Review
The Dr. Scholl's Shoes Women's Brilliance Wide Calf Riding Boot in Black is a fan-favorite designed to provide a perfect blend of timeless style and versatility. This boot stands out as an eco-friendly option, featuring a toe box, linings, and topcloth made from recycled materials that showcase the brand’s commitment to sustainability. The faux leather construction enhances its appeal with soft and feel-good linings, ensuring all-day comfort.
Related Products
Features
- Sustainably Crafted: Eco-conscious fabric components made from recycled bottles.
- Materials: Faux leather with soft linings for added comfort.
- Fit: Inside zip and hidden stretch gore for effortless wear.
- Sustainable Comfort: Anatomical cushioning provided by advanced insole technology.
- Movement: Lightweight and flexible design that adapts to your movements.
- Style: Sleek tall boot with trendy metallic buckle detail and a 1 and 1/4 inch stacked block heel.
- Great for All Occasions: Suitable for various activities including walking, shopping, and office wear.
Pros
- Eco-friendly materials contribute to sustainability.
- Comfortable anatomical cushioning supports foot health.
- Versatile design complements different styles and occasions.
- Wide calf options available for better fit.
Cons
- Style may not appeal to everyone due to the riding boot aesthetic.
- Some users might find the fit snug if they are between sizes.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Height | Eco-Friendly |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Scholl's Shoes Women's Brilliance Boot | Faux Leather | Knee-high | Yes |
| Clarks Women's Aileen Dusk Boot | Leather/Synthetic | Knee-high | No |
| Naturalizer Women's Kelsey Tall Boot | Leather | Knee-high | Yes |
Detailed Review
Design: The design of Dr. Scholl's Women's Brilliance Wide Calf Riding Boot is sleek yet functional. With its metallic buckle detail, it adds a touch of modern elegance to your outfit. The knee-high shaft offers versatility, making it suitable for both casual and formal attire.
Comfort: One of the standout features is the insole technology that provides exceptional anatomical cushioning. Whether you're walking or standing for long periods, your feet will appreciate the support this boot offers. Additionally, the lightweight and flexible construction allows for natural movement, so you won't feel restricted.
Sustainability: Being sustainably crafted, these boots are a great choice for environmentally conscious consumers. The use of recycled materials in the construction speaks volumes about the brand’s initiative towards reducing environmental impact.
Fit: The inside zip and hidden stretch gore make it easy to slip the boots on and off, while also accommodating wider calves. However, for those who are typically between sizes, it's advisable to try them on first to ensure the best fit.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Design | 4.5/5 | Stylish and modern with a classy finish. |
| Comfort | 5/5 | Excellent cushioning and support for all-day wear. |
| Durability | 4/5 | Well-made but may require care depending on use. |
| Sustainability | 5/5 | Strong focus on eco-friendly production. |
| Fit | 4/5 | Good fit with wide options, though size considerations apply. |
User Reviews
I wear a 7.5, but I had to get this in an 8 as my feet are short but wide and this shoe has a narrow shape. This worked out well as my foot is snug but not constricted, and the wide calf fits my 17-inch calves perfectly. Not much wiggle room and no stretch in his area, so if you have calves that are 17.5in or larger, I'd pass on this shoe. Find something with garter material. I know if I wear thick, tall boot socks these will be too snug, so stockings or leggings with crew socks will have to do for these. The ankles are a little baggy but that's expected; if you're looking for a clean slim line that makes your legs look long and sleek, this isn't going to be perfect, but it works for me. The heel is the perfect height as it gives my legs a great silhouette without ax excessively high heel. Over all it's exactly what I'm looking for.
These boots are so comfortable. They fit well, are sturdy, and are stylish to boot (pun completely intended). I would order these time and time again!
I’m so sad because these are such good quality and beautiful, but fit very snug! The foot is very narrow and not wide calf at all.
So disappointed, they look amazing. I work an office with carpet. I Hardly walk, a wore them maybe 6 times in total and the heel is peeling. Is really just paper. The sizing is wrong too. Half size smaller. My husband threw away my box and I can't return it.. but so sad. They look dressy and the calf fits perfect but poorly made.
They fit just right, look with everything I wear.
Size:: This is not the first Dr scholl's shoes I've owned. Previously, I have bought a size 10 which is my normal size. So that is what I ordered. I feel like they fit appropriately.Wide Calf Size:: there is a smidge of extra room around the top of my calves but not by much. I recently lost 45 pounds & I fear that if I hadn't done that these probably would not have fit my calves. Not sure what the calf width is compared to other side calf boots, something to consider when deciding to purchase.Comfort:: As always with Dr Scholl's shoes, the foot bed in the shoes are cushioned and comfortable. I have worn these once for running errands on a very cold rainy day. They kept my feet and calves dry & very warm.However, after an hour and a half of walking and driving, walking and driving my feet became very sore along the sides of my pinky toes as well as the ball joint of the feet. I've never needed to buy wide shoes for comfort reasons in the past, so I believe this is something that will fade away as the boots wear in. The heel is very slightly higher than boot heels I've bought in the past so that may okay a role as well.The boots are a somewhat soft leather like feel but also stiff in a manner that they stand on their own. You don't have to stuff the boots for them to stand upright in the closet.Durability:: I was disappointed to see that the heel is beginning to peel where the heel meets the soul of the shoe after only one wear. Something I'll have to keep an eye on, possibly super glue down if this becomes more noticeable.Packaging:: I appreciate that these boots are not bent in half on the claf & instead are packaged upright with no bending to the boots. I always feel this cheap poor packaging trick wears the boots down before you even buy them so I was happy to see the packaging!Overall:: I really like the boots! I think they're a classic style that won't fade away. They can easily be dressed up or down. For the price I think you get what you pay for. They're nice boots that seem durable considering they're not genuine leather. Contemplating a purchase of them in black!
The boots seem like good quality, but they run small and narrow. However, the calf size was adequate for wide calves. I returned the item.
Comfortable, casual, true to fit , BUY THEM . I have a little bit of a full calf , they fit great. Heel height is perfect.