Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Monk-Strap Loafer Black 11 D Review
The Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Monk-Strap Loafer is a sophisticated shoe designed with versatility in mind. Featuring a classic double monk strap style, this shoe effortlessly elevates any outfit, whether you're dressing up for a formal event or going for a more casual look. The black leather finish offers a timeless appeal, while the cap-toe design with perforated brogue detailing adds an element of refinement that is hard to overlook.
Related Products
Features
- 360º Bench Welt construction for exceptional durability and stability.
- CustomCork insole that molds to your foot for a personalized fit.
- Single oak leather sole for a premium feel.
- Handcrafted in Port Washington, WI using fine imported materials.
- Built on the reliable welted 1943 Last for a classic fit.
Pros
- Elegant design fits well for various occasions.
- High-quality craftsmanship ensures longevity.
- Comfortable fit thanks to CustomCork insole.
- Versatile enough to be dressed up or down.
Cons
- Initial stiffness may require a break-in period.
- Higher price point compared to other loafers.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Sole Type | Fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allen Edmonds St. John's Monk-Strap | Leather | Leather | True to size |
| Johnston & Murphy Melton | Leather | Rubber | True to size |
| Brogue by Paul Evans | Leather | Leather | True to size |
Detailed Review
The fit and comfort of the Allen Edmonds Men's St. John's Monk-Strap Loafer are commendable. With its CustomCork insole, it provides excellent support, adapting to the shape of your foot over time. While some users may experience initial stiffness, the effort put into breaking them in is often rewarded with unparalleled comfort.
In terms of design and aesthetic, this shoe is a standout. The combination of the classic monk strap, cap toe, and brogue details creates an upscale look suitable for both business and social settings. It's a versatile addition to any wardrobe.
The durability of the shoe cannot be overstated. Thanks to its 360º Bench Welt construction, you can expect a pair that will maintain its form and function through regular wear. Handcrafted in the USA from high-quality imported materials, these shoes are built to last.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 4.5/5 | Exceptional comfort after break-in. |
| Durability | 5/5 | Constructed to withstand regular use. |
| Style | 5/5 | A timeless design that fits various occasions. |
| Value for Money | 4/5 | Premium price reflects quality craftsmanship. |
User Reviews
Please listen to the other reviews that said this vendor is selling damaged merchandise. The shoe box lid was cut and one of the straps on the shoe was detached. The other shoe was fine so it wasn’t part of the design. Even if they hadn’t been defective, the sizing was way off! Go try on and buy shoes in a store even if you pay more!
The product was a used set of shoes !! Returned it
I have two pairs of AE shoes and noticed a lack of quality with this particular pair. There was noticeable fraying near the top of the shoe along with some warping in the leather. Doesn’t seem like a genuine AE product.
I was very disappointed by this purchase. The package did not come in original packaging the shoes were just in a large box indicating some sort of explanation that the original packaging had been damaged or destroyed there are some marks on the shoes. I'm assuming these are factory seconds as they don't appear to be up to quality standards.
They are not even close to what Allen’s shoes look like…. Don’t waste your time or money.