Allen Edmonds Mens Plymouth Walnut Monk Straps Review
The Allen Edmonds Mens Plymouth Walnut Monk Straps are a versatile addition to any gentleman's wardrobe. These plain-toe single monk strap dress shoes effortlessly blend classic sophistication with modern functionality, making them suitable for both formal occasions and casual outings. Each pair is handcrafted in Port Washington, WI, using fine imported leathers that ensure not only aesthetic appeal but also long-lasting durability.
Constructed with a 360º bench welt, these shoes provide exceptional stability while allowing your feet to remain comfortable throughout the day. The premium European calfskin leather enhances the overall look and feel of the shoe, while the custom cork insole molds naturally to your foot for a personalized fit.
Related Products
Features
- 360º bench welt construction for durability and stability
- Custom cork insole that molds to your foot
- Single oak leather sole for added elegance
- Handcrafted in Port Washington, WI, with fine imported leathers
- Built on the 201 last for a classic fit
- Premium European calfskin leather used for outer material
- Soft tan leather lining for enhanced comfort
- Recraftable for sustainability
Pros
- Exceptional craftsmanship and durability
- Comfortable custom fit due to cork insole
- Stylish design suitable for various occasions
- Recraftable, extending the life of the shoe
Cons
- Higher price point compared to mass-produced options
- Limited color choices may not suit everyone's taste
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Welt Construction | Insole Type | Recraftable |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allen Edmonds Plymouth Walnut | European Calfskin Leather | 360º Bench Welt | Custom Cork | Yes |
| Johnston & Murphy Conard | Full Grain Leather | Goodyear Welt | EVA Foam | No |
| Sperry Top-Sider Avenue | Leather | Not Specified | Padded Insole | No |
Detailed Review
Comfort
The comfort level of the Allen Edmonds Plymouth Monk Straps is one of their standout features. The custom cork insole adapts to your foot shape over time, providing support where you need it most. Whether you're attending a business meeting or enjoying a night out, these shoes will keep you comfortable all day long.
Durability
Crafted with precision, these shoes boast a 360º bench welt construction that enhances stability and durability. The premium materials used ensure that they withstand the test of time, making them a worthy investment for your footwear collection.
Style
With their classic single monk strap design, these shoes can elevate any outfit, from tailored suits to smart-casual ensembles. The rich walnut color is particularly stylish and adds a touch of sophistication wherever you go.
Recraftable Feature
One impressive aspect of the Allen Edmonds Plymouth Monk Straps is their recraftable nature. When the soles wear down or if the leather shows signs of age, you can send them back to the company for refurbishment, which not only extends their lifespan but also promotes sustainable fashion practices.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9.5 | Excellent cushioning and fit due to custom cork insole |
| Durability | 9.0 | High-quality materials ensure long-lasting wear |
| Style | 9.5 | Timeless design suitable for various occasions |
| Value for Money | 8.5 | Higher initial cost but worth it for quality and longevity |
User Reviews
As expected from AE, excellent craftsmanship and they look very stylish. Slim appearance but not too narrow in the foot bed. Highly recommend for a long lasting great quality dress shoe.
These are nicely designed shoes . These run larger than normal . Sole isn’t great and is wearing out fast
Take a look at the pictures I posted.The bad: I received the shoes with a tear in the leather of the left shoot where the stitching comes together. I noticed it out of the box but didn't know what it was until I went to a local shoe cobbler. She asked if the shoes were a "factory second" and if I paid full retail price. I told her I did pay full retail and she said that it wasn't acceptable.More bad: The right heel counter is appropriately 1 cm high than the left. It caused pain from day one. I tried to break it in, did everything recommended on the Allen Edmonds website and then noticed this issue.The last bad: See my last picture, the stitching is coming out of the left shoe and a tear in the leather on the side was noticed. I wear overshoes, I work in an office building. I've never seen such a thing and I've only worn cheaper dress shoes with worse leather.The good: The left shoe was comfortable and seemed to fit well from day one. Besides the above issues, they seemed to be good quality otherwise.Unfortunately, I am going to return them. This was my first purchase of a high quality shoe and I am disappointed. I read much about how a higher quality shoe could last a decade or longer. Mine lasted a couple of weeks. Back to cheaper shoes for me.
I've wanted a pair of Allen Edmond shoes for 7 years. I was so excited when I got home to check out my new shoes! ...and you can see the pics for yourself. And there are problems with both of them.Inside sole isn't even attached in one of them! Cuts in the heels and leather. Staining in the leather (and not just normal stain variation). The stitching is messy in many places. Frayed leather... In short, I'm absolutely convinced they sold me a poorly executed, refurbished pair of shoes.(Not relevant to you guys) But if AE somehow sees this, just wanted to personally thank you for being the cherry on top of a day I already grieve on.