Allen Edmonds Men's Randolph Penny Loafer Dress Shoe, Walnut, 8.5 US Review
The Allen Edmonds Men's Randolph Penny Loafer in walnut is an excellent choice for those seeking a sleek and refined footwear option suitable for both formal and casual occasions. Handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin, these loafers combine premium European calfskin leather with exceptional craftsmanship, ensuring you not only look sharp but also enjoy long-lasting comfort.
Related Products
Features
- Slip-on design for easy wear.
- Classic fit: order your regular size.
- Handcrafted from imported materials.
- Ultra-refined, premium European calfskin leather uppers.
- Durable 360º bench welt construction.
- Luxurious leather lined interior.
- Single layer vegetable-tanned leather soles for a sleek profile.
- CustomCork insoles that adapt to the unique shape of your foot.
- Built on the 79 footwear last for a comfortable fit.
Pros
- Elegant design suitable for various occasions.
- High-quality craftsmanship ensures durability.
- Comfortable CustomCork insoles provide great arch support.
- Versatile style pairs well with both dress and casual outfits.
Cons
- Higher price point compared to other loafers.
- Requires some break-in time for optimal comfort.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Allen Edmonds Randolph | Clarks Men’s Bushacre 2 | Aldo Men’s Alben |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | European Calfskin Leather | Suede | Leather |
| Construction | 360º Bench Welt | Cemented | Cemented |
| Insoles | CustomCork | Textile | Foam |
| Style | Penny Loafer | Desert Boot | Dress Loafer |
Detailed Review
The Allen Edmonds Men's Randolph Penny Loafer stands out in the realm of men's footwear due to its exquisite design and superior quality. The use of premium European calfskin leather gives these loafers a luxurious sheen, making them appropriate for both the office and more relaxed settings such as family gatherings or outings with friends.
Upon wearing the loafers, you will appreciate their slip-on functionality, allowing for quick and effortless wear. The CustomCork insoles are particularly noteworthy, as they mold to the unique contours of your feet over time, providing personalized comfort that is hard to find in similar products.
Durability is another key characteristic of the Randolph loafer, thanks to its 360º bench welt construction, which reinforces the shoe's structure and stability. While the soles are made from vegetable-tanned leather, which contributes to their low-profile look, they do require some care to maintain their appearance and longevity.
However, bear in mind that these shoes may feel stiff initially and could require a break-in period. Additionally, the price might be a deterrent for some, especially when compared to more budget-friendly alternatives. Nonetheless, investing in a pair of Allen Edmonds loafers can pay off in terms of style and comfort.
In summary, if you are searching for a stylish yet functional dress shoe, the Allen Edmonds Men's Randolph Penny Loafer is a commendable choice that delivers on both aesthetics and performance.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Design | 9/10 | Elegant and versatile, suitable for various occasions. |
| Quality | 10/10 | Exceptional craftsmanship with premium materials. |
| Comfort | 8/10 | Great comfort after break-in, custom insoles help. |
| Value for Money | 7/10 | Higher price point, but quality justifies it. |
User Reviews
Allen Edmonds always produces a great fitting shoe. Workmanship and quality are first class. Purchased the shoe even though out of stock. Paid $265 on sale for the penny loafer which normally is $400. The shoe delivery was one week ahead of the projected delivery date. Shoe size is 13C which is a narrow width and hard to find. Allen Edmunds has a good selection in this size. The shoes are very comfortable durable and it fits right out of the box. No break in needed.
Nice quality but, a tight fit on one foot. I have an old pair of Brooks Brothers loafer but, newer versions are not the same quality. I tried these, hoping they would be the replacement I'm looking for - they didn't. I'll work with them, hope they loosen up I guess... Glad I don't have to wear these every day!!
I love Allen Edmond shoes, even though I do not purchase very often since I retired. I did recently buy the Randolph Penny Loafer in a size 11 N, and was pleased that the quality of Allen Edmond shoes still meets high standards. Also I am always very pleased to find a man's dress shoe in a narrow size. Even though I used to wear penny loafer's in high school, AE has modernized this classic shoe so it is stylish and looks good. These shoes will serve me well for many years.
The shoe size runs a little big. Not to horrible but I have to wear thicker socks with them. But then again they are Allen Edmonds enough said. Major quality shoes. I feel aristocratic when I wear them. LOL.
Durable, comfortable, true to size
beautiful shoes! Has a very classy look and the fit is awesome.
The shoes was too wide so returned it within days and its about a month now and have not yet got a refund.Have called couple times to get a status update for the refund but the refund date gets pushed each time you call. Beware and do not buy these shoes its nothing but a pain to get the money back.
I love these because off the fact that AE brand,and what they stand for.They're comfortable,stylish,and very sturdy! I love everything about AE.