Salewa Wildfire Edge Mid GTX Approach Shoe - Men's Java Blue/Onyx 11.5 Review
If you're in search of a versatile approach shoe that seamlessly transitions from hiking to climbing, look no further than the Salewa Wildfire Edge Mid GTX. This shoe is engineered for those who demand both precision in their climb and comfort on their trek back. Perfectly suited for varying weather conditions, this unique solution caters to alpinists, climbers, and scramblers alike.
The key feature of the Wildfire Edge is the Salewa Switchfit system, which allows you to easily tighten or loosen the fit based on your activity. When you lace up tightly, your foot is pulled forward into the toebox, mimicking the snug feel of a climbing shoe. Once you've reached the summit, simply relax the laces for enhanced hiking comfort.
Related Products
Features
- Upper: 1.6mm suede leather, Exa Shell Over Injected 3D Cage, Microfiber
- Lining: GORE-TEX Extended Comfort
- Insole: Edging Plate, EVA
- Outsole: Pomoca Speed MTN Pro
- Footbed: MFF+
Pros
- Excellent climbing performance with enhanced stiffness
- Versatile fit adapts from hiking to climbing
- Durably waterproof and breathable GORE-TEX lining
- Lightweight construction allows for easy movement
- Good traction on both wet and dry surfaces
Cons
- Can be pricier than other approach shoes
- Adjustment of lacing can take time to get used to
- Limited color options available
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Salewa Wildfire Edge Mid GTX | Scarpa Drago | La Sportiva Tarantula |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waterproof | Yes | No | No |
| Switchfit System | Yes | No | No |
| Weight | Lightweight | Moderate | Heavy |
| Edging Performance | High | Very High | Moderate |
Detailed Review
When evaluating the Salewa Wildfire Edge Mid GTX, several aspects stand out. The first is the fit and adaptability; the Salewa Switchfit system is revolutionary, allowing for a tailored experience whether you're navigating rocky terrains or making technical climbs. The compression at the toes improves performance without sacrificing comfort during descents.
The shoe's construction is impressive, with a mid-cut upper made of high-quality 1.6 mm suede leather that provides both durability and breathability. Coupled with the GORE-TEX Extended Comfort lining, your feet remain dry even in adverse weather conditions, while still being able to expel perspiration efficiently.
Another noteworthy component is the Pomoca Speed MTN Pro sole, which excels in providing grip on various surfaces. Whether you’re traversing slick rocks or muddy trails, the well-spaced tread blocks ensure that you maintain stability and traction. The precision climbing zone at the toe offers added confidence when tackling difficult ascents.
However, one must consider the learning curve associated with adjusting the lacing system, which may take some getting used to. Additionally, the premium features do come at a higher price point compared to standard approach shoes.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Exceptional comfort for long hikes and climbs with adaptive fit. |
| Performance | 9.5/10 | Outstanding climbing performance with excellent traction. |
| Durability | 8.5/10 | High-quality materials ensure long-lasting use under varied conditions. |
| Value for Money | 7.5/10 | Higher initial investment but justified by superior performance. |
User Reviews
They definitely run about 1 size small. So I normally wear 11 and a 12 fit perfectly. I bought these to wear at work and I honestly love them as far as comfort, traction and style. However, that nylon ankle ring at the top is exactly what it looks like...These boots are not easy to put on so be prepared. Alternatively, they won't come off easily, which is important in my line of work. They also aren't particularly warm, so if it's about 40 F you'll likely feel it if you aren't constantly moving. They are a niche footwear and they are awesome if this is the type of shoe you need. Not just for climbing. If you care about solid support and a lightweight, durable shoe with amazing traction and a badass look...this is it.
PROS: An excellent boot -- should be a contender for any through-hiker / trekker looking to cut weight. Fits well, and given the lacing system can be adjusted as needed. It is in fact WATERPROOF and BREATHABLE. Whaaaaat? Unheard of ... moderately thick sole with great traction, good ankle support. I am 6'3" and 210 lbs -- so light weight boots generally do not work so well for me -- as they often do not provide sufficient ankle support and/or protection for the soles of my feet. This is a MUCH better boot than most -- for carrying up to 20-25 lbs of weight, touring, trekking as well as moderate off trail activities.CONS: Does not provide much protection for your upper feet in mixed terrain. The boot sole thickness and the ankle support are insufficient for me to use them for heavy packing. Three season only. But SALEWA did not advertise the boots as such ... so no complaints.SUMMARY: light weight, water proof, breathable, great fitting -- not sure what else you could ask for in this type of boot. Buy it, or get stuck with M*rrils, and any of the other over priced poorly designed "boots." Your call ...
Wear boots out fast. If you spend extra for comfort...there is no better boots on the market. Tried them all. Only dislike is the addition of the velcro on moldable sock tongue. First pair I got were no velcro. Much better. But I get why they had to go with the velcro. Not everyone's feet are the same so velcro adds up to more comfortable fit overall.
I've now had two pair of these boots. The first, seemed to have a small manufacturing defect which caused some of the pull loop to protrude into the inner boot at the back of the ankle. It took about two months of blisters to get that worn in. They became my favorite boots after the rough break-in period. The boots were quite waterproof, at least until I dropped molten brass on them... (** Side note, don't expect these to just pull off your feet) I ordered a second pair and found them to be much more comfortable right out of the box. I have about 20 miles on this new pair and no blisters or complaints so far. I have yet to submerge the second pair, however, I feel like they are likely to be just as waterproof as the first. (Barring any molten metal incidents, for which they are clearly not cut out.)
So these are my go to every day boots. I’ve had the boots already for about a month and a half, and I will say this to you when it comes to waterproof skid resistant sea on a roof or wet surface it has held up well! I love the Velcro at the top, and the tread underneath is high qualityMy only negative is the insoles*** quickly wore down for me after a WEEK, I do a lot of walking, sometimes jogging around the house, but this is a simple fix other than that they have worked well for me. If you’re someone who doesn’t constantly expose them selves to the elements, these will last. I will do a follow up review at the end of June.** Well it’s not the end of June just yet in the boots are holding strong. I had to get some other insoles and after that it’s like a premium, feel all together!Walked my dog through puddles not a drip on my socks, jumped on the roofs off of a ladder great grip, no slip. These are worth a dollar don’t second-guess stop scrolling buy try leave your own review well worth it. I will be back for another pair. Hopefully they go on sale.
First pair of boots that I want to wear year round. I can stand in the OR all day and not experience any back pain. This is my first Salewa purchase and I have become an instant fan.I bought them because I have more clients in colder climates. After months of research, I bought a few pairs of tactical boots that had soles that were appropriate for snow and ice. However, I needed something that was waterproof as well. I also wanted boots that I would not need to take off in the hospital. Fell in love with the aesthetic design from the picture. Bought my first pair and was shocked at the perfect fit out of the box. Wore them all day the next day and bought my second pair that night. Your feet can generate about a 1/2 cup of sweat each day. It is good to give boots a day to dry out even if they did not get wet. It is best to not wear the same boots everyday. Bought a 3rd pair just in case the model is discontinued.
I do not have wide feet. I wear regular shoes and boots. The toe box in this shoe is so small that when I put my weight into them the outside of the boot would move. There was so much pressure on the outside of my foot that it hurt to just stand in them. The other issue I was having is my heal was moving a lot when I walked. I could tell these would lead to blisters if you didn't put band aids on your heal. They are really cool looking boots and I love the lacing system. Yes i tried all different ways to lace them but there just wasn't enough room in them. The material on the inside of the boot is also rough. Buy a size up and wear thick socks. I'm upset that I have to return them. I really wanted these to work for my job. I never made it out of the house. If you have narrow feet and want to wear these in a cold climate they would work for you. I bought them to work security and there is no way I could stand in these all night.
Only have a few outings in these so far, but ultimately I love them. Snug fit, even after ordering a half size larger than normal, but they fit like a glove. Personally, I don’t find getting them on & off to be a challenge and I’m liking the elastic top as well. I don’t leave many reviews, but I’m really digging these shoes.