Mountain Warehouse Collie Women's Waterproof Hiking Shoes Review
The Mountain Warehouse Collie Women's Waterproof Hiking Shoes in black are designed with the adventurous woman in mind. As you embark on your hiking journeys, these shoes promise to keep your feet dry and comfortable thanks to their innovative features. Constructed specifically for the outdoors, these walking sneakers blend style with functionality, making them a fantastic choice for both casual strolls and challenging hikes.
Features
- IsoDry: This waterproof and breathable material ensures that moisture escapes while preventing rain from seeping in.
- Waterproof Construction: Made with a water-resistant upper and a reliable waterproof membrane.
- Softshell Outer: Offers excellent freedom of movement and ventilation, ideal for warmer conditions.
- EVA Cushioning: Moulds perfectly to your foot, providing exceptional support and comfort on long treks.
- Phylon Midsole: Lightweight and flexible cushioning foam enhances overall comfort during your adventures.
Pros
- Excellent waterproofing keeps feet dry even in heavy rain.
- Breathable material helps maintain comfort during warmer hikes.
- Lightweight design reduces fatigue over long distances.
- Good traction thanks to the rubber sole, ensuring stability on various terrains.
Cons
- Size may run small; trying on before purchase is recommended.
- Limited color options available.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Waterproofing | Breathability | Cushioning | Sole Material |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mountain Warehouse Collie | Yes | Yes | EVA | Rubber |
| Merrell Moab 2 Ventilator | Water-resistant | Yes | Compression Molded EVA | Vibram |
| Salomon X Ultra 3 GTX | Yes | Yes | Ortholite | Contagrip |
Detailed Review
The Mountain Warehouse Collie Women's Waterproof Hiking Shoes shine in multiple categories. Firstly, the waterproof feature stands out as one of its best attributes. Whether you encounter unexpected rain or muddy trails, these shoes stand up to the challenge, keeping your feet dry and comfortable.
In terms of comfort, the combination of EVA cushioning and a Phylon midsole allows these shoes to adapt to your foot's shape. This adaptability makes them suitable for extended use without causing discomfort or pain, which is crucial for any hiking adventure.
Additionally, the softshell outer contributes significantly to overall breathability. It allows for proper air circulation, which can be particularly beneficial during hikes in warmer climates. However, if you're planning to wear these shoes in colder environments, additional insulation might be necessary.
On the downside, some users have noted that the sizing can be a bit tricky; hence it's advisable to try them on if possible, or consult the size chart thoroughly when ordering online. The limited color options could also deter those seeking more personal expression through their footwear.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 4.5/5 | Exceptional fit with great cushioning for all-day wear. |
| Waterproofing | 5/5 | Outstanding moisture protection, keeping feet dry in wet conditions. |
| Traction | 4/5 | Reliable grip on various surfaces, providing confidence while hiking. |
| Breathability | 4/5 | Good airflow, ideal for warm weather but may lack in colder climates. |
| Durability | 4.5/5 | High-quality materials ensure longevity, withstands rigorous outdoor activities. |
User Reviews
I bought this shoes to work in the yard and I’m fire fighter/ first responder. My feet were getting wet in my old shoes and with these shoes their not. I’m in love with them. They are pretty comfy! I would buy this brand again. The only bad thing is they don’t come in half sizes.
Very cute hiking shoe or walking or for me To be and a body shop not have to worry about ruining my sneakers slipping or getting my feet wet now have not tested the water part because it has not rained yet but so far these fit a little too big but I have found that hiking shoes do run large it would be nice if this brand carried half sizes a 7 and a 1/2 would be perfect for anyone who wears a size 8 they are a bit wide there is good cushion in the Heel. You will definitely want to wear a higher sock or an ankle sock with a heel tag otherwise I promise you will get a blister but other than that no complaints so far looking forward to testing them out with the water may exchange due to them being a little large but we shall see
great hiking shoes and waterproof. They fit perfectly but they were stiff when first putting them on so needed to break them in for a few days before wearing them hiking. I'm a 7.5 and i ordered an 8 and it was just right.
Really wanted to like these because the look is MUCH smarter than most other waterproof walking shoes. They look more like a comfortable everyday trainer that can be worn around town as much as out on trails. I tried the size 9 first because I usually need to go half a size up with a bulky hiking shoe, but they were massively big, so much that I could just slip them off like a boat shoe even when laced tight. Decided to give the 8 a try because I liked the look and they seemed like they'd be comfortable and supportive in the right size. The 8 *almost* worked but were just a bit narrow in the toebox and the upper was stiff and kept creasing right across my little toe. Wearing them half the day to do some furniture moving around the office was enough to tell me these wouldn't work well for an all-day town and country walking holiday. Alas, sending these ones back as well and continuing the search for a smart, comfortable trainer that won't leave me with wet feet on rainy days.
Fell apart after using a few times. Do not recommend. Very bad quality.
I bought them for my trip to Israel year 2019, they were perfect in all the different weather we experienced, heat my feet stayed cool, rain and puddles my feet stayed dry, we did ALOT of walking up hills on rocky grounds and they were very comfortable, they are still in GREAT shape. I am very please with these shoes. worth every dollar I spent on them!!
This shoe would probably have worked in all the ways described above, except it hit the malleolus bones (bone on outside of ankles) making it very uncomfortable. I even tried a different insert to give my feet more height inside the shoe to avoid this but then I was almost walking out of the shoe with the heel slipping. I cannot comment on water resistance as I did not wear them very long to test that out and wanted to be sure they were in new condition when I returned them. The seller gave me a refund with no problem. I was sad that these shoes did not work for me, as otherwise, they were a very nice shoe and I could have really used them in caring for my horses.
sturdy. and comfy - I wore them out of the box with no issues on a long walk. I'm a size 6 and there was a bit of room in these - so I would say they run on the slightly larger side but I won't change them as I wear thick socks and an insole anyway. Love the colors. Haven't tested them in rain yet but feel confident they will be waterproof. Good value!