Columbia Women's Redmond III Waterproof Hiking Shoe, Cordovan/Black, 7.5 Wide US Review
The Columbia Women's Redmond III Waterproof Hiking Shoe is engineered for adventurers who seek a reliable companion across diverse terrains. With a combination of long-lasting comfort and protective design, these shoes are built to withstand the rigors of outdoor activities while ensuring your feet remain comfortable and secure.
The upper is crafted from a blend of suede leather and breathable mesh webbing, allowing for a snug fit that promotes airflow, keeping your feet cool during hikes. This shoe doesn't just boast comfort; it also features the Omni-Tech waterproof construction, ensuring that wet weather won't dampen your outdoor experiences.
Related Products
Features
- Omni-Grip non-marking traction rubber outsole for superior grip
- Techlite lightweight midsole providing lasting comfort and high energy return
- Waterproof breathable construction to keep feet dry
- Synthetic leather overlays for added protection
- Gusseted tongue to prevent debris from entering
- Molded toe cap for enhanced durability
Pros
- Excellent waterproof capabilities
- Durable and flexible materials used in construction
- Comfortable fit with good cushioning
- Versatile design suitable for various outdoor activities
- Good traction on different surfaces
Cons
- May require a break-in period for optimal comfort
- Some users report sizing discrepancies, so trying on is recommended
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Weight | Waterproof | Traction Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Columbia Women's Redmond III | Lightweight | Yes | Omni-Grip |
| Merrell Moab 2 Waterproof | Moderate | Yes | Vibram |
| Salomon X Ultra 3 GTX | Lightweight | Yes | Contagrip |
Detailed Review
Comfort: The Techlite midsole in the Columbia Women's Redmond III provides exceptional cushioning and support. Whether you're trekking uphill or navigating rocky paths, you will appreciate the balance of firmness and softness that minimizes foot fatigue.
Fit: Many users find this shoe true to size, but given the variety of foot shapes, it's wise to try them on if possible, especially since there’s a wide option available. The combination of leather and mesh ensures a snug yet breathable fit.
Traction: The Omni-Grip traction rubber outsole excels at providing grip on both wet and dry surfaces. Whether you're crossing streams or walking on sandy beaches, you'll feel stable and confident in your movements.
Durability: Designed for tough conditions, the use of synthetic leather overlays not only protects against abrasions but also adds to the overall lifespan of the shoe. Users report consistent performance over time even with regular use.
Overall Performance: In conclusion, the Columbia Women's Redmond III Waterproof Hiking Shoe stands out for its comfort, stability, and waterproof features. It's a solid choice for anyone looking to enhance their outdoor adventures without compromising on quality.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 4.5/5 | Exceptional cushioning and support for long hikes. |
| Traction | 4.8/5 | Superior grip on various surfaces. |
| Durability | 4.7/5 | High-quality materials that withstand tough conditions. |
| Waterproofing | 4.6/5 | Effectively keeps moisture out in wet conditions. |
| Value for Money | 4.4/5 | Good pricing considering performance and longevity. |
User Reviews
Sturdy And comfortable. Replaced my 20 year old Timberline hiking boots with these. These fit nicely even though I have a wide foot.
Long big dog walks are no problem, very comfortable and dry in this wet area
I like them. They look good, good support, good soles (fyi I use them casually), but they run a little narrow, and the shoe laces are short.I don't have wide feet, but I had to loosen the laces up considerably to fit comfortable, but that leaves me with next to nothing to tie the shoes. I have a comically small knot to keep them on. Planning on replacing the laces eventually, (if I can find something similar).Overall I like the shoes, I just wish they at LEAST had longer shoe laces
I really liked my shoes. I'm still breaking them in, but they are comfortable and warm. I thought the tongue could be a bit longer to give a bit more stability and I did not test their waterproof quality yet, but so far, so good.
Hi,I am going to try to not rate these uless I am forced to because I have not really worn them yet; however, I ordered my regular size but it felt a bit small. So i ordered 1/2 size larger. The half size larger felt better than the regular size. They also felt "like a running shoe." They were not uncomfortable but they had a tight feeling on the sides. I will rate these after I wear them for a while. I kept them because they are waterproof and the price. The length is fine with a half size up, but they still feel short. I felt this was important iformation so I wrote the review before I wore them.
Comfortable fit, great for my daily 7 mile walk.
Fits and wears great
My favorite shoes are 10 wide men's of this exact model bought years ago. Starting to wear out so wanted to get a replacement. Bought the same size as before and what arrived was NOT 10 wide but maybe 9.5 medium. Could barely get one of the shoes on and impossible to walk in comfort. Compared my old 10 wides to this pair and the old ones visibly wider. The tongue on the old ones specifically stated "wide" but the tongue on these did not. But the box for this shoe stated "wide." Conclusion is the factory put medium shoes in boxes labeled wide. Previous reviews indicating undersizing that I initially dismissed as outliers now confirmed by personal experience that a systemic issue is present.Bought a replacement pair from the Columbia website that arrived and fit fine and say "wide" on the tongue.Glad these were returnable.