Columbia Women's Redmond III Waterproof Hiking Shoe Review
The Columbia Women's Redmond III Waterproof Hiking Shoe is your go-to footwear for any adventure. Whether you're trekking through muddy trails or strolling on dry ground, these shoes are engineered to provide the support and stability you need. Featuring a combination of suede leather and breathable mesh webbing, these hiking shoes not only ensure durability but also keep your feet comfortable and cool.
With an Omni-Grip traction rubber outsole, these shoes excel in providing stable footing across various surfaces, making them ideal for both outdoor terrains and indoor wear without leaving marks. The true-to-size fit adds to the appeal, ensuring that each step you take feels snug yet comfortable.
Related Products
Features
- Advanced Technology: Omni-Tech membrane bootie with seam-sealed construction ensures waterproof protection.
- Durable Hiking Shoe: Designed for high functionality and nimble multi-terrain performance.
- All Terrain Traction: Signature Omni-Grip non-marking outsole provides excellent grip.
- Built for Comfort: Synthetic leather overlays enhance fit and support, while the gusseted tongue keeps dust out.
- Reinforced Construction: Extra protection on toe and heel barriers for wet conditions.
Pros
- Waterproof design keeps feet dry in wet conditions.
- Excellent traction on various terrains.
- Lightweight construction enhances comfort during long hikes.
- True-to-size fit allows for easy selection.
Cons
- Some users may find the need for a break-in period.
- Limited color options compared to other brands.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Columbia Redmond III | Merrell Moab 2 | Salomon X Ultra 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waterproof | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Traction | Omni-Grip | Vibram | Contagrip |
| Weight | Moderate | Moderate | Lightweight |
| Fit | True-to-size | Varies by style | True-to-size |
Detailed Review
The Columbia Women's Redmond III Waterproof Hiking Shoe stands out in the hiking footwear market due to its thoughtful design and advanced features. Let's delve into various aspects of this shoe:
Comfort: The Techlite lightweight midsole offers cushioning and energy return that is hard to match. Many hikers have found these shoes exceptionally comfortable even after hours of wear.
Traction: Thanks to the Omni-Grip outsole, this shoe provides remarkable grip on wet rocks, loose gravel, and muddy trails. This feature instills confidence when navigating tricky terrains.
Durability: Constructed from high-quality materials, including reinforced toe and heel sections, the Redmond III exhibits long-lasting performance. Users have noted how well they hold up over time, making them a reliable choice for regular hikers.
Versatility: While primarily designed for hiking, their non-marking soles make them suitable for indoor use as well, allowing for seamless transition from trail to home.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Exceptional cushioning and supportive fit. |
| Traction | 9/10 | Outstanding grip on various surfaces. |
| Durability | 8/10 | High-quality materials with reinforced areas. |
| Value for Money | 8/10 | Great performance for the price. |
User Reviews
I waited to review these until after I put them to the test. These were the only shoes I needed for two wintry weeks in Europe, traipsing over cobblestones, melting slush piles, ice, and mud. I stayed upright on the frozen-over puddles while my husband, wearing regular running shoes, was slipping and sliding. Cleaned up, they looked fine for city touring as well. These shoes were waterproof, warm, comfortable with a very short break-in period, and are now my new favorite shoes for any kind of offroad or rough surface exploring. I think they will last a long time, but I'm considering buying a second pair in another color because I like them that much. As far as sizing, I normally wear a 7 wide in athletic shoes. I went up to a 7.5 wide in these to accommodate thick winter hiking socks. My feet have wide toes and narrow ankles (so kind of flipper-shaped) and are nearly impossible to fit. Keens are wide enough, but have heels that slip on me. These are secure in the heel without crunching my toes. Another win for Columbia in my travel closet!
Bought for trip to Ireland. Pretty comfortable as we did a lot of walking. Like that they are waterproof also.
Great fit, finish, and looks. Nothing to complain about. Will see how long they last.
This is so comfortable. It feels like I’m walking on the clouds. Great for hiking and trails. However, it gets very warm very fast. Wouldn’t recommend for very hot days
I have wide feet and these fit me. These are my favorite shoes for my days off.
I volunteer at a shelter, cleaning kennels and walking the dogs. These shoes are truly non-slip when cleaning the kennels, and there is a lot of water used. Also, after walking the dogs, I have to rinse my shoes off before cleaning kennels, and my feet do not get wet when rinsing the bottom of the shoes. They help keep me steady on the various types of terrain around the shelter, as I am prone to a sprained ankle and wearing these shoes truly helps. While I do have a wide foot, these do seem to be a little bit wider than most white shoes. But with an ankle brace on, it's not a problem.
I like the shoes. They fit well but just a few days after wearing, the stitching where the toe cap meets the mesh part kind of pulled a bit. They don't seems to be unstitching, bit just looks likes the quality check was lax.
I took a chance and bought these shoes just before going on a long trip, not knowing if they would be comfortable enough to wear every day. I had never worn Columbia shoes before, so I didn’t know what to expect. I was happy to learn the shoes felt great for the duration of the trip. They offered good support and a nice feature: The tongues are sewn in place so I didn’t have to pull them into place all the time. They do feel a bit heavier than regular walking shoes, but not enough to present a problem. Great shoes at an excellent price.