Dr. Scholl's Shoes Men's Winder II Slip Resistant Work Loafer, Black Leather, 11.5 Wide Review
The Dr. Scholl's Shoes Men's Winder II Slip Resistant Work Loafer combines professionalism with optimal performance, making it an ideal choice for those looking for a reliable work shoe. This loafer is designed for men who value both comfort and style while on the job. Made primarily from leather, it features an oil-resistant, slip-resistant Lock Step Outsole™ that meets stringent SATRA TM63 and TM144 standards for safety.
With its anatomical cushioning and support, the insole technology ensures that your feet remain well-cushioned throughout the day. The lightweight construction promotes effortless movement, allowing you to navigate your work environment with ease. If you're in search of a stylish yet functional work shoe, this could be a fantastic option.
Features
- Performance tested: Exceeds industry average for comfort and cushioning
- Leather upper with manmade materials
- Elastic goring side panels for easy slip-on
- Memory Foam Cool Fit insole for anti-compression support
- Slip-resistant and non-marking rubber outsole
Pros
- Exceptional comfort with excellent cushioning
- Stylish oxford design suitable for professional settings
- Lightweight construction that moves with you
- Easy on/off slip-on style
- Durable and oil-resistant outsole for added safety
Cons
- May not fit true to size for all users
- Limited color options available
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Comfort | Slip Resistance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Scholl's Winder II | Leather | High | Yes |
| Sketchers Work Sure Track | Synthetic | Medium | Yes |
| Caterpillar Second Shift | Leather | Medium | Yes |
Detailed Review
The Dr. Scholl's Shoes Men's Winder II deserves a spotlight for its thoughtful design aimed at professionals. From a comfort perspective, the combination of memory foam and anatomical cushioning makes these loafers an excellent choice for long hours on your feet. Users consistently report reduced foot fatigue, which is critical for anyone in demanding work environments.
When it comes to performance, the slip-resistant outsole combined with the oil resistance means you can confidently wear these shoes in various settings without worrying about safety hazards.
The style factor cannot be overlooked either. The classic oxford design paired with black leather makes them versatile enough for both formal and casual workplaces. This adaptability adds significant value, ensuring you look as good as you feel.
However, sizing can be a bit tricky; some users have reported that the 11.5 wide may not fit perfectly according to their expectations. Additionally, while the shoe is mainly durable, a few customers noted the desire for more color options to match different outfits.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Outstanding cushioning and support for prolonged use. |
| Performance | 8/10 | Exceeds safety standards; reliable for various work conditions. |
| Style | 7/10 | Classic design suitable for a range of work environments. |
| Fit | 6/10 | Some inconsistencies in sizing reported by users. |
User Reviews
I've bought these for years in black and brown. When the soles get worn out I retire them from office duty and use them for work (outside, mechanic work). Comfortable from day one, no break-in and hold up without polishing.
Comfy for long shifts on feet, easy to slip on/off, antislip thick bottoms, look nice, second pair I’ve owned and will buy again
This is great in literally every aspect. Great traction, great look, great comfort, ( And I say this as someone who owns a Hoka Bondi 8 and a Brooks Glycerin GTS 20, both of which are famous for comfort), outstanding slip on access without any trouble with the heel having a hard time getting in, and I've worn it for a while now. However. Though this would be a five star review if all these things were the only thing I'd write about, there was one inconvenience. Nothing big. But yet nothing too small either. The weight of the shoe feels like as though you will be getting a leg workout just walking around in them all day. So if you are always on the go, and always on the move at your workplace without catching a break every now and then, I do not believe this is the shoe for you. However, if you have a moreso stagnant role that requires you to move around and have brief periods of still activity than I'll gladly fully recommend this one to you. Overall though as a waiter in a fine dining restaurant, I am fully satisfied with these, and honestly my managers even wished they had them as well as the other coworkers.. They just have a certain look to them that screams professionalism. Which is why even though there is somewhat a problem with the weight, I'm still very content with them.
Very comfortable and easy to clean. No blisters or wet feet!
I purchased these after my local stores stopped carrying a less expensive Dr. Scholl's work shoe. I figured a more expensive upgrade of the same basic form factor shoe with the same company would suit me fine but I was extremely disappointed:1. The shoes are way too large for the size listed. I've never had a shoe in my size be this loose. It's way beyond the variation normally encountered between brands/models. I had to wear two pairs of socks and use an aftermarket heel insert to make them at all wearable.2. The sole started deteriorating and peeling off after less than a week of light wear. It's a thin non-slip layer that is glued on. I had to use shoe glue to reattach it but it didn't last long and I shouldn't have to do repairs on a pair of shoes after owning them for less than a week.3. The upper isn't durable. While walking up stairs I lightly stubbed the toe and later discovered gouges that showed the gray base below. The description says 100% leather but if that's the case it's a very thin layer. The less expensive model of Dr. Scholl's work shoes I used to get were much more durable. I would expect scuffs with normal wear but not chunks taken out.It's really too bad, this would have been a great pair of shoes and served my purposes very well if only the quality, durability and sizing were decent. I'll have to find a better alternative and although I've had good experiences with other Dr. Scholl's shoes in the past, this particular model, Winder II, really let me down.
After only about a month of weekday desk job use the insoles have deteriorated around the heels of each shoe. The fact that these are Dr. Scholl's makes poor insoles completely inexcusable as a point of failure.The length is good, however, the width lets my foot constantly slide and roll side-to-side. The shoes are also very loose around the top and the heel. enough that have to walk like they are a pair of slides/flipflops or they just flop right off my feet. I will say the build quality, other than the insoles, seems excellent so far. If you have chubby/bulky/wide feet or always rock some extra thick winter socks and get replacement insoles these are passable shoes.
comfortable fit
Well made sizing is accurate. Made to last