Trotters Women's Lucy Flat, Cognac - An In-Depth Review
The Trotters Women's Lucy Flat in Cognac is a beautifully woven flat shoe designed for those who prioritize comfort without compromising on style. Crafted with a commitment to quality since 1935, Trotters has made a name for itself by combining the finest materials with innovative design. The Lucy Flat showcases this legacy perfectly, featuring a unique comfort footbed that makes walking a pleasure.
Each pair is thoughtfully constructed using 100% leather, ensuring durability and an attractive finish. With a man-made sole that's flexible and lightweight, these flats adapt seamlessly to various surfaces, making them ideal for both casual outings and professional settings.
Related Products
Features
- Comfort flat with a flexible design
- Lightweight for all-day wear
- Available in extended sizes for a perfect fit
- Crafted from 100% leather
- Imported quality with a slip-on closure
Pros
- Exceptional comfort due to high-tech cushioning
- Stylish woven design suitable for various occasions
- Multiple size options available for hard-to-fit feet
- Durable construction using premium materials
Cons
- Limited color options compared to other brands
- Some users may find the price point on the higher side
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Closure Type | Size Availability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trotters Women's Lucy Flat | 100% Leather | Slip On | Extended Sizes |
| Clarks Women's Brixby Shore Flat | Leather/Synthetic | Slip On | Standard Sizes |
| Naturalizer Women's Saban Flat | Leather | Slip On | Wide Width Options |
Detailed Review
Design: The Trotters Women's Lucy Flat boasts a stylish woven exterior that adds a touch of elegance to your ensemble. The cognac hue lends itself well to various outfits, making it a versatile addition to your wardrobe.
Comfort: The standout feature of the Lucy Flat is undoubtedly its comfort. Thanks to the specially developed comfort footbed, you can expect excellent support even after hours of wear. The cushioned interior molds to the shape of your foot, providing a personalized fit that enhances overall comfort.
Fit: Trotters focuses on fit with a separate last designed for each size and width, allowing you to find the perfect fit easily. This is particularly beneficial for individuals with unique sizing needs.
Dressing Versatility: Whether you're heading to work, running errands, or enjoying a weekend brunch, the Lucy Flat adapts effortlessly to any setting. You can dress it up with slacks or keep it casual with jeans.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Excellent cushioning and support make them great for all-day wear. |
| Quality | 8/10 | High-quality materials ensure durability but come at a premium price. |
| Style | 9/10 | Stylish design that complements various outfits. |
| Fit | 9/10 | Extensive size range allows for a personalized fit. |
User Reviews
I have bought and enjoyed Trotters before and am delighted with these shoes and this style. The size I ordered was a perfect fit. The color is true and very rich looking. They are very comfortable to wear, but I think I will try to find an insole to provide a bit more padding. The elastic sling back keeps the strap from slipping and the shoes stay securely on my feet. They are finished very nicely on the inside - no rough spots to irritate the skin. I would definitely order these again.
I don't know what happened to all the prior customer reviews that were present on this site -- I relied on them prior to my purchase. Anyway, I was wearing a 10-B in all makers until this past year when I developed, along with my bunions, the beginning of an ingrown great toenail. Ok, TMI ... but, I have to let anyone who is looking at this know. So now, instead of a size 10B, I search out leather only and in size 10.5-B. Hard to find that size, but they are available. This way, I get about 1/4 inch longer and the crazy toe box shapes are not as painful! I got this shoe on a fantastic sale in the Ivory size 10.5-B. The length is perfect; my heel does not 'hang over' the back and my toes are not scrunched up front. However, as the lady who mentioned wearing them with socks for a few days said, they are tight in the WIDTH of the toe box. So, I will wear these around home for several days to try to break them in. If that doesn't work, I'll try a shoe stretcher, although I hate that because the results are always 'iffy'. I do love the style, and hate the dressy flats with the paten toe boxes - because the seams hurt my toes, no matter which ones I've purchased. And I've purchased hundreds of shoes over the years, and done damage to my feet. I'm on my feet all day and need comfortable shoes. I really feel that with Trotters, once these are 'broken in' in the toe box, that they will be very comfy. Not sure I'd spend $90 for a pair, but for what I got them for, it was well worth the price.BOTTOM LINE: you may want to go up 1/2 size, as the actual shape is a rounded off toe box that probably started out on the drawing board as an awful pointed toe. Also, because the last reviewer and myself both felt the toe box is tight, you may also want to increase your width size -- ie, instead of a b, get a C. The weaving seems very sturdy, and the mfg is well know and usually excellent, but I'm not sure how stretchy they will become. I do not think they will stretch out of shape, more like stretch to conform to your individual foot. Good luck!
Nice looking shoe, but runs size small
This is a very cute sling back shoe and it goes well with several of my spring/summer outfits. However with a bunion on my left foot, the shoe feels tight. My local shoe repair shop was able to gently stretch the toe box area of both shoes and now they are comfortable. The color is great and the sole is durable. The heel strap is a good fit; no blisters.
I love Trotter shoes and this is my favorite style so I was really excited when I saw it on Amazon. When the shoe arrived the box was old, worn & torn. The fit was perfect but the shoe was awful. They look plastic and one of them had a black spot on top. Plus it was clearly a "second" since the back strap was not "finished" it was rough, seams were not covered, the bare elastic rubbed against the heel. I am returning the shoes & will go back to DSW Shoes.
Shoe was too tight on my foot.
I have long, skinny feet (11 2A) and these fit perfectly. I am adding more arch support, but that may just be me. It is a great looking, comfortable shoe.
Nice shoes but too tight