Naturalizer Womens Samantha Comfortable Pointed Toe D'Orsay Slip On Ballet Flat Review
Step into a world where feminine elegance meets contemporary design with the Naturalizer Womens Samantha Comfortable Pointed Toe D'Orsay Slip On Ballet Flat. Crafted from luxurious black suede leather, these flats are not just shoes; they are an embodiment of comfort and style that cater to today’s modern woman. The pointed toe and D'orsay-side cutout create an exquisite silhouette that is perfect for various occasions, making them versatile additions to your wardrobe.
Related Products
Features
- Polished D'Orsay flat shoes with a low hidden wedge heel for added lift and comfort.
- Ballerina flats made with leather, metallic leather, suede, or leather/suede upper featuring a classic pointed toe.
- Contour+ Comfort technology ensures a premium fit for all-day wear.
- 1-inch hidden wedge heel with a non-slip outsole designed for easy everyday wear.
- Conscious packaging with 100% of shoe boxes made from 80% recycled paper and soy-based ink.
- Timeless design using sustainable materials makes these shoes a great choice for eco-conscious consumers.
- Perfect for indoor or outdoor use, office settings, casual outings, date nights, weddings, parties, and more.
- Available in an inclusive size range, including wide width options, ensuring a comfortable fit for every foot type.
Pros
- Exceptional comfort due to Contour+ Comfort technology.
- Stylish D'orsay design suitable for both casual and formal occasions.
- Sustainable construction with eco-friendly packaging.
- Non-slip outsole provides stability.
- Inclusive sizing options available, catering to wide feet as well.
Cons
- Some users may find the hidden wedge heel less suitable for those who prefer completely flat shoes.
- Availability in certain sizes may be limited due to high demand.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Material | Heel Height | Comfort Technology |
|---|---|---|---|
| Naturalizer Womens Samantha | Suede Leather | 1 inch | Contour+ |
| Clarks Women's Talia Jade | Leather | 0.5 inch | Cushion Soft |
| LifeStride Women's Parigi | Faux Leather | 1 inch | Soft System |
Detailed Review
The Naturalizer Womens Samantha Flats stand out due to their exquisite design and thoughtful features. Whether you're navigating a packed office or heading out for a casual dinner, these flats offer a blend of fashion and functionality. The D'orsay-style side cutouts provide breathability while maintaining an elegant profile.
One of the standout aspects of these flats is the Contour+ Comfort technology, which is designed to conform to the shape of your foot for enhanced comfort. This is particularly beneficial if you plan to wear them throughout the day, as they ensure support without compromising on style.
The hidden wedge heel gives you just enough lift without sacrificing comfort, allowing you to feel confident no matter the occasion. Plus, the non-slip outsole means you won't have to worry about traction, making these flats an ideal choice for both indoor and outdoor events.
In terms of sustainability, Naturalizer's commitment is evident through their use of eco-friendly packaging and materials, providing an additional layer of appeal for environmentally conscious shoppers.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 4.5/5 | Exceptional comfort thanks to the Contour+ technology. |
| Style | 4.7/5 | Modern D'orsay design suits various occasions. |
| Durability | 4.3/5 | High-quality materials promise longevity. |
| Value for Money | 4.5/5 | Offers great value given the quality and comfort. |
User Reviews
There was no question in my mind that these would be adorable, but I wasn't sure about how they would feel.My feet are crankier than most, so it's hard for me to find shoes that are both cute *and* comfy. I'm happy to report that these get an A+ rating for cute, and an A- for the comfort factor.The pointed toe is super flattering and pairs perfectly with wide-leg pants, which usually make my short legs and small feet look swamped. Of course, these shoes have the same elongating effect when paired with almost anything else, as well. And the beige color is the perfect spring / summer neutral.The comfort was the most surprising to me. While these don't seem to have a lot of arch support, they do have enough cushion to keep my feet happy for light office or evening wear. The leather gives a bit and is breathable, and the elastic inserts were a stroke of genius design to keep these flexing instead of tugging at delicate foot skin. I had mild discomfort wearing these on the first few hot days, but I haven't had a single blister during or after wearing them.Alas, they do have a pointed toe, so that means the toe box is less forgiving if your foot is wider in the front. I do notice some restriction in this area, to the extent that I probably wouldn't wear these two days in a row. But it's not enough of a comfort issue to keep me from wearing them weekly.
Super stylish flats for work! I plan to purchase these in several colors! Perfect for work and extremely comfortable. I’m especially impressed with the quality. I walk every lunch break and these still look brand new. I would however recommend using some kind of protective spray for the suede. I wear a size 8 and found these to run a tad big, not big enough to size up as I personally have wider feet. I get compliments on them all the time. Love love love
Purchased this pair and another color in the black leather/suede in a size 6. I like how the flats look and it's perfect for the office. I'm hoping the flats will stretch out in the front after a few wears because they are constricting and I don't even have wide feet.The flats did rub my heels raw because they were loose on me. I ended up putting heel grips on them and now they fit much better. I do love the fact that the flats are have more cushion than most flats. Still on the fence if I should keep the black pair.Update:I purchased these flats in the nude leather and black suede/leather. The nude pair was tight on my toes but it should stretch over time. The suede pair was more comfortable out of the box! I still needed to add a heel grip otherwise my feet slips right out due to my lack of heels.I highly recommend the black suede/leather pair. It’s very comfortable and I didn’t need to break them in.Increased 1 star in my review.
Honestly, I have not had on a pair of dressy shoes in two years. I am diabetic and my feet hurt constantly so I wear Ugg slippers in black and try to wear longer pants so it is not noticeable. However, I have a couple of events coming up and I did not feel good about wearing even brand-new Uggs. I looked and looked and ordered these d'Orsay copycat shoes. They arrived, and I looked at them and thought, I can never wear these. They look too nice and stiff. Not true, I took the stuffing out of them. They have a wonderful insole and they are extremely comfortable. I wore them out today for the first time, out for 2 1/2 hours, walked about 100 to 150 yards and they still do not hurt. I highly recommend them, so far so good. They look very classy. My sister does fashion shows for over 50 and she said: "You look fabulous today." She does not just pass out compliments.
Let’s start with why I love these... they’re gorgeous, the quality is good, they don’t slide on the floor, and the caramel color is unlike anything I’ve seen. It has almost a shimmer to it.But there are unexpected problems that are why I’m sending them back:1) let’s start with the shimmer. It’s a love hate. Love because it’s gorgeous. Hate because it gives the shoes a blue cast in bright sunlight. Think pearly iridecent just not in your face. I was trying to buy a neutral shoe. But I also love the color. Just not what I was trying to buy right now.2) padding: I would rather have no padding than padding that doesn’t work with my foot. The pad that’s supposed to be for the ball of my foot is at an odd and uncomfortable spot for me. And because it’s not padding throughout, it’s a little bubble of uncomfortable.3) there is a bit of a small wedge hidden in the shoe. Take a close look at the pictures and your’ll see it. Maybe a half inch when you add the tiny heel that you see on the outside but I was looking for flats. This wasn’t a deal breaker but it did add to the problem with the padding.3) there is a tiny elastic gusset. Sure this means the shoe will probably fit more people BUT it will wear out faster than leather and it turns the right shoe into a flip flop for me (my right foot is slightly smaller than my left.) At the time I purchased this it wasn’t mentioned in the description and isn’t something you’ll notice in the pictures unless you are looking for it.These are a SLIM shoe. I expected this going in but I’m going to note it for people who don’t wear a lot of pointed toe dress flats. I typically wear an M width but in certain styles it’s a bit loose for me. I can not wear a W width shoe ever. This shoe in a M fits closer to a N. BUT it’s also leather which means they should stretch a bit on wearing them and conform a bit to your foot... if you can tolerate them for a day. Width was exactly as I expected it but if you usually wear round toes shoes, you might want to take that into consideration.So ... sadly they are going back. One of the surprises above wouldn’t have caused me to send them back (maybe the padding) but all three is just too much. The padding issue though will keep me from buying this style in the future. Honestly I was really hopeful I would love this shoe because there are so many colors!I have included photos though. No color correction done and you can really see how much the color of the caramel shoe changes with the change in the lighting and has a bluer cast to them with sunlight.