Dr. Scholl's Shoes Women's Islander Strappy Flat Sandal Review
The Dr. Scholl's Shoes Women's Islander Strappy Flat Sandal in Tawny Birch Microfiber is the ultimate choice for those who want to combine style with sustainability. Designed with a breezy look that perfectly embodies vacation vibes, this sandal not only elevates your outfit but also supports eco-friendly practices.
Crafted from microfiber made from recycled plastic bottles, these sandals come with soft linings that ensure all-day comfort. The design features stretchy gore straps, making it easy to slip on and off while providing a snug fit. With a lightweight and flexible construction, you can move freely without any restriction, making them ideal for various casual occasions.
Related Products
Features
- SUSTAINABLY CRAFTED: Soft linings made from recycled bottles.
- MATERIALS: Microfiber made from recycled plastic bottles.
- FIT: Slip-on design with stretch gore straps for effortless wear.
- SUSTAINABLE COMFORT: Anatomical cushioning and support through Insole Technology.
- MOVEMENT: Lightweight and flexible design enhances mobility.
- STYLE: Strappy casual sandal with contoured footbed and faux wood wedge heel.
- CONSCIOUSLY PACKAGED: Shipped in recyclable materials using soy-based inks.
- GREAT FOR ALL OCCASIONS: Suitable for walking, driving, shopping, and daily activities.
Pros
- Eco-friendly construction from recycled materials.
- Comfortable and supportive footbed.
- Slip-on design with easy-to-use stretch straps.
- Lightweight, making them perfect for long wear.
- Stylish appearance suitable for various occasions.
Cons
- Limited color options may not suit every personal style.
- Some users may prefer a more rigid sandal structure.
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | Dr. Scholl's Islander | Competitor A | Competitor B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Microfiber (recycled) | Canvas | Leather |
| Footbed Type | Anatomical Cushioning | Padded | Orthotic Support |
| Weight | Lightweight | Medium | Heavy |
| Adjustability | Stretch straps | Buckle | None |
| Eco-Friendly | Yes | No | Yes |
Detailed Review
Design and Aesthetics: The strappy design of Dr. Scholl's Islander Sandal offers a casual yet chic look that's perfect for summer outings. The Tawny Birch color adds a warm touch, allowing it to easily complement a variety of outfits.
Comfort Level: True to its promise of sustainable comfort, the anatomical cushioning offers a pleasant experience for your feet. Many users report no discomfort, even after extended periods of wear, which speaks volumes about the insole technology used in these sandals.
Ease of Use: The slip-on design with stretch gore straps makes putting on and taking off the sandals a breeze. This feature is particularly beneficial when you're on the go, needing quick and hassle-free footwear.
Versatility: These sandals are great for almost any occasion—from casual walks in the park to running errands or an easy day at the office. However, they shine brightest during leisurely outings where comfort meets style.
Eco-consciousness: If sustainability is important to you, the fact that these sandals are constructed from recycled materials adds an extra level of appeal. Not only do you get to enjoy stylish footwear, but you also contribute to reducing waste.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Highly comfortable with excellent cushioning. |
| Style | 8/10 | Fashionable and versatile for various occasions. |
| Fit | 8/10 | Slip-on design fits well but may require adjustment for some. |
| Sustainability | 9/10 | Constructed from recycled materials, highly eco-friendly. |
| Value for Money | 7/10 | Good quality but may be considered premium compared to basic options. |
User Reviews
I LOVE THESE!Comfort - What I consider to be the most important thing, these are one of the most comfortable sandals I have ever had! The straps aren't too tight, and if so, they're so stretchy I don't think they would be uncomfortable. The bottom (where your foot rests) is soft but supportive. I have walked miles in these as though they were tennis shoes just because I could! Chasing after a toddler never posed to be an issue either. The top of the sandal is also roomy, and large enough to allow your feet to move as they were designed to. Nothing ever felt squished.Design - They're just cute! I feel like this is an "in" style and maybe I'm out of the loop or just in my mom era, but I also just loved how they looked on and off of me. It's important! We like stylish yet comfort!The only downfall to this shoe is that the beige on top of the sandal has occasionally gotten something on it and because of the color it stands out like a sore thumb. Things fall on shoes, they get dirty. I truthfully have not tried to scrub it out yet. BUT if your shoes stay clean forever, kuddos to you and you will love this sandal!
I just got these shoes and tried the on and DAMN, are they so comfortable! I got these to replace my plain flip flops, as I'm going on a trip soon, and I wanted a pair of comfortable sandals that are slingbacks to replace my $40 comfortable flip flops, so theyll be less weight and strain on my feet as I walk. I noticed immediately that they put less force, weight, and strain on my hips whenever I walk. They're cute too! And they are the perfect size, I got 9 as the amazon formula reccomended. I'm usually an 8 in stores, but Ive noticed that on amazon Im a size 9 in terms of footwear, at least, thats how its been for the last two pairs of shoes I've ordered online on Amazon. Def would reccommend!
These look like boats on my feet and I bought my normal size. They are cute and they are comfortable and fit snuggly, so that’s the plus side. I bought these to have something cute to wear while in Vegas that I can walk around in without my feet falling off. It’s just strange because the show feels like it fits perfectly but the toe box is slightly too long. I’m afraid to go a half size down as I feel my toes would be sitting right on the edge.
This is the third year in a row that I've purchased these sandals. Last year I even bought multiple colors, but my fave one is the Tawny Birch because it's neutral and goes with everything. Before you balk at the fact that I've been replacing them annually, consider that I live in NYC, walk miles every day, and spend a significant amount of time chasing a toddler in them. These are super cute and can be dressed up in a summer dress or down in shorts. I get tons of compliments on them. They are true to size and provide excellent support for my archy feet. I usually wait for a sale to pick a pair up and find $50~ to be super affordable for this level of comfort. I'm sitting here on a random Wednesday telling the internet that I love these sandals, so you can safely say I'm a big fan.
I wore these for my first time in Thailand walking along the streets in Bangkok. It could by the humidity, but I got numerous blisters that trip from these shoes. They are cute and fairly comfortable minus the blisters so I had high hopes. Makes sense for the price though.
I'm a teacher, so I'm on my feet walking around all day. I found my feet really hurt at the end of the day so I went on the hunt for cute but comfortable sandals, and these are it!I wear these all of the time, and they're great! Cute and comfortable without looking or feeling like I'm wearing "old lady" shoes.
I was so excited to get these as I’ve had good experiences with Dr. Scholls sandals in the past. Upon first try on they were a good fit and comfortable (comfortable straps, low height with some support, not too flat), but once walking around they started giving me really painful burning/rubbing sensation under the ball of my foot, eventually leasing to blisters. I always expect some wear in period and blisters from sandals at the start of a new pair and even each new summer season getting my feet back into sandal season, especially with the amount of walking we do in nyc, but these are sadly unbearable. I’ve never had such a strong painful burning feeling on the ball of my foot or from a regular blister. It’s like the material of the inner sole is just causing too much heat and friction with every step. Very painful. I kept trying them again seeing if they needed to break in, but no luck and even used blister / corn protector pads, but the friction rips them off my feet. I have to now just get rid of them after only a couple months.
These are so comfy. Walked around all day with these on. Stretchy elastic not tight at all after all day on my feet ! And my feet tend to swell a bit in warm weather but these were never too tight. And they’re a little dressier than flip flops