Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Amy Lug Sole Mary Jane Black Review
The Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Amy Lug Sole Mary Jane in black is more than just a shoe; it's a statement piece that perfectly blends British punk style with collegiate charm. The chunky silhouette is designed for those who want to stand out while maintaining comfort. With its distinctive buckle closure, this shoe not only adds flair but also speaks volumes about your fashion sense.
Related Products
Features
- Fabric type: 100% Synthetic
- Care instructions: Machine Wash
- Origin: Imported
- Sole material: Synthetic
Pros
- Stylish design that combines punk and collegiate aesthetics
- Comfortable lug sole for all-day wear
- Easy-to-clean synthetic fabric
- Versatile enough to pair with various outfits
Cons
- May not fit everyone perfectly due to the chunky design
- Limited color options available
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Product | Style | Material | Care Instructions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Circus NY Women's Amy | Mary Jane | Synthetic | Machine Wash |
| Dr. Martens Jadon | Platform Boot | Leather | Wipe Clean |
| Breckelles Chunky | Oxford | Faux Leather | Spot Clean |
Detailed Review
When it comes to footwear that combines style and comfort, the Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Amy Lug Sole Mary Jane stands out in several key areas:
- Design: The distinctive chunky heel and rounded toe give this shoe a bold profile. This design choice allows you to express individuality whether you're dressing up for an event or keeping it casual.
- Comfort: Thanks to its synthetic sole, these shoes provide substantial grip and support. The lug sole is particularly useful for long days on your feet, ensuring that you feel as good as you look.
- Versatility: Whether paired with jeans, skirts, or dresses, the classic black color allows for endless styling possibilities, making it a great addition to any wardrobe.
- Care: With machine wash capability, maintenance is simple, which is a significant plus for those who value convenience in their footwear.
Overall, if you are looking for footwear that seamlessly combines edgy style with functionality, the Circus NY Amy Lug Sole Mary Jane will likely exceed your expectations.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Design | 4.5/5 | Bold, unique look that captures attention. |
| Comfort | 4/5 | Supportive sole suitable for extended wear. |
| Versatility | 4.5/5 | Easily pairs with a variety of outfits. |
| Care | 5/5 | Simple maintenance for busy lifestyles. |
User Reviews
These lasted me two months before the sole cracked underneath and collapsed internally i also bought a different pair of circus i need to return because they have zero arch support or cushioning and also my mom bought circus shoes she had to get rid of because they hurt.. so i mean if you want a cgeap pair of shoes they youll only wear like 20 times then these amys are fine but tgeyre also for bigger feet and overpriced for the quality sadly
I like these a lot and they pretty comfortable for the 10 seconds that I tried one on.Some weird inconsistencies though. Like the belt buckle strap bands.. for some reason one is super tight and squeezes the strap and kinda dents it (where you tuck in the strap as show in the pics on both shoes) and the other fits the strap perfectly fine.Another thing I noticed was the way it seems to be glued around the soles. This wouldn’t be a major issue for me if these shoes weren’t nearly $80. Not that that’s expensive I just expect a bit more quality for that price. I will return these and order the same exact pair in the same exact size again and see if there’s any difference. Speaking of size I’d say they’re true to size but if you want to socks maybe size up. Tights/stocking would be fine though.Update: I ordered the second pair to compare and see if it was just one off and while the issues I had were resolved I noticed some new things that overall made the shoe a no FOR ME. Not to say these aren’t still cute af and you shouldn’t buy them. Just not for me.The soles were fine on the second pair so we’re the buckles. Everything fits perfectly. But I noticed (the last picture w socks) that the flap that connects the top of the shoe to the buckles are going to crease NO MATTER WHAT. And while I do love the platform on this shoe, it’s a little too WIDE (not too tall) for me to pull off the look I’m going for. After awhile staring at them and deciding, it started to look like a clown shoe. Sad face. Really wanted to keep these even thought they weren’t worth $75+ more like 67 hard max. Will be returning.
This shoe is very heavy. Uncomfortable, After 40 minutes of wearing this shoe I was walking like a a Gazelle! Taking its first steps. Although great to look at; not an everyday walking shoe. Unless your into 10-12 ponds of weights. If you want to purchase mines, you get them for half the price. Only woren for half a day.
My daughter absolutely loved this shoe and it was so disappointing that the buckle broke after 2 months of wear. I don’t see any way to contact the company who made them. So I do not recommend purchasing them.