ECCO Women's Modtray Penny Loafer, Black, 9-9.5 Review
The ECCO Women's Modtray Penny Loafer is not just another shoe; it’s a statement piece that combines edgy street style with sophisticated comfort. Crafted from smooth, full-grain leather, this moc-toe penny loafer embodies elegance while ensuring you feel at ease whether at the office or out and about. The lightweight lugged sole equipped with innovative ECCO FLUIDFORM Direct Comfort Technology provides exceptional cushioning and flexibility, enabling you to navigate your day effortlessly.
Related Products
Features
- Lightweight lugged sole for cushioning and flexibility
- Rubber outsole with ECCO TRAYTECH Technology for stability and grip
- Crafted from durable, full-grain leather
- Lined in leather for a luxurious feel, paired with breathable textile
- Removable, molded leather inlay sole for customizable comfort
Pros
- Stylish design suitable for various occasions
- Excellent comfort even during extended wear
- High-quality material ensures durability
- Versatile enough for both casual and formal settings
Cons
- Limited color options available
- May require a break-in period for optimal comfort
Comparison With Other Similar Products
| Feature | ECCO Women's Modtray Penny Loafer | Clarks Women's Octavius Amaze Loafer | Naturalizer Women's Kiki Loafer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Full-grain leather | Leather and synthetic | Leather |
| Closure Type | Pull-On | Slip-On | Slip-On |
| Cushioning Technology | ECCO FLUIDFORM | Ortholite insole | Naturalizer N5 Contour |
| Outsole Material | Rubber | Rubber | Manmade |
Detailed Review
Style: The ECCO Women's Modtray Penny Loafer stands out with its sleek and modern look. The black leather finish complements a variety of outfits, making it an excellent choice for both work and leisure. Its stylish design allows you to transition seamlessly from the office to dinner outings.
Comfort: Comfort is a standout feature of this loafer. The ECCO FLUIDFORM technology ensures that the shoes mold to your feet, providing personalized comfort right out of the box. The leather lining adds to the overall plushness, making these loafers ideal for long days on your feet.
Durability: Made from high-quality, full-grain leather, the Modtray Loafer promises longevity. ECCO’s commitment to craftsmanship means that these shoes can withstand daily wear, making them a worthy investment for your wardrobe.
Versatility: These loafers can be dressed up or down, making them a versatile addition to your collection. Pair them with tailored trousers for a sharp office look, or wear them with jeans for a casual yet chic style.
Detailed Rating
| Category | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Style | 4.5/5 | Modern and elegant design perfect for various occasions. |
| Comfort | 4.8/5 | Exceptional cushioning and fit, great for all-day wear. |
| Durability | 4.7/5 | High-quality materials ensure lasting performance. |
| Versatility | 4.6/5 | Easily pairs with different outfits for multiple settings. |
User Reviews
Very nice! Love it
These shoes are super comfortable. I tried to size down to 8/8.5 as recommended, but they were too narrow. I needed a 9/9.5. I wear a size 9. I've received a ton of compliments. Highly recommend this shoe!
The break in period gave me blisters. I have to buy insoles and and blister covers. Took about 2 weeks to break them in. Now that they’re molded to my feet, I get compliments all the time and can wear them with no pains. Good quality shoes!
After stretching them on my job in the office - wearing it for four hours per day, these shoes are still uncomfortable and hurt my feet a lot. They also squeak as I walk. They make my feet sweat.I kept them because of the construction and the material are substantial and of high quality.However, the left shoe is much wider and longer than the right shoe. This is the second pair with Ecco’s shoes. Left shoe feels like 1/2 size larger than the right - but it was marked as if these shoes were the same.I kept them but wouldn’t walk in these on the street - they will hurt my feet on the asphalt road.Maybe one more year of stretching and they will be my favorite.
On the black version of this loafer, there is a white rubber strip that wraps from the bottom around to the side of the sole. The other colors have a similar strip, but in a darker color that makes it inconspicuous. Why would Ecco ruin a beautiful black loafer with his tackywhite strip? So disappointing!😢
It's more mauve than pink or rose, but it's sort of an ugly mauve. I bought them because this color was on sale. If you're on the fence about the color, pass on them.
The front was very long, so my usual 9 was too big. Didn’t try an 8.5 yet.
Very comfortable loafer. Other reviews mentioned not liking the white detail on the sole, but I thought it made the shoe more interesting. I own other Ecco shoes and boots and these were unfortunately much too big. Normally wear a 37 (6-6.5) in Ecco. These fit more like a 38 (7-7.5). Will be returning. Also small nit picky detail—box was crushed and smelled bad, like it had been stored in a damp basement. Kind of put me off ordering another pair in the right size.